
case-13- ããã§ãåãå ¥ããçŸå Ž ããã®ïŒã
case-13- Â ããã§ãåãå
¥ããçŸå Ž Â ããã®ïŒã
â»ã¹ã¿ãããé¢ãã£ãæ¹ã®åå幎霢ã¯å
šãŠç§ã䟿å®äžé©åœã«ã€ããä»®åã§ãã®ã§ããå®å¿ãã ããã
ååã®èšäºã§èªç¥çã«ãªããããè·çš®ãæããã圌女ãŒå
æ©ããããã®1人ã ã£ãã
60æ³ã§ãŸã è¥ãã®ã«ã¢ã«ããã€ããŒåèªç¥çãé
ä¹±ã®å€«ãæ¯åã¯çè·åž«ãšã€ã³ããŒãšäžåŠçãšãããªããªãããŒããªå®¶ææ§æã
圌女ãèªç¥çã«ãªã£ãã®ã¯é
ä¹±ã®å€«ã圱é¿ããŠããã®ã ããããææã®æ¯åãé ãæãžå°±è·ããã®ã§å¿ãå£ããŠããŸã£ãã®ããç¥ããªãã
æ¯ã®èªç¥çã«é©ããçè·åž«ã®é·ç·ã¯ãè·å Žè¿ãã«å¯®ãåããŠäœãã§ããã®ã«ãæ¯ã®çºã«æ¯æ¥1æé以äžå®å®¶ãžåž°ãé¢åãã¿ã€ã€çè·åž«ãšããŠã®ä»äºãããªãããšããããšããããŠããã
圌女ãå®¶ã«çœ®ããŠãããšé
ä¹±ã®å€«ãšå§å©ã«ãªãã®ã§åŒãé¢ãçºã«å€æ¹ãŸã§æ¯æ¥ãã€ãµãŒãã¹ã«éã£ãŠæ¬²ããããšã®ãªãŒããŒã§ã圌女ã¯å®ã«å¹Žæ«å¹Žå§ä»¥å€ãã»ãŒäžž1幎äŒãŸãã«ãæ¥æãããã
ãããã¯åœŒå¥³ãšé¢ãã£ãåœæã¯ç¬é¡ã®çŽ æµãªãã°ã¡ããã ãªããšæã£ãŠãããã3ã¶æãããªããã¡ã«ã圌女ã¯è±¹å€ããããããã©ã€ããŒããã«æãããŠããŸãã圌ãåºå€ãããšãã£ãšä»ããŸãšãã
ããããããªãã°è¯ããããã©ã€ããŒãããšä»ã®ã客æ§ã楜ãããã«ã話ãããŠãããšãããããã®ç·ãåããªãã§ïŒããšæ®Žãæããã
å¿è«ãå
æ°ãªæ¹ãæ¯èŒçå€ããã€ãµãŒãã¹ã ãåã£çµã¿åãã®å§å©ãæ¢ããã®ã¯1床ã2床ã§ã¯ãªãã
ããæ¥ã«ã¯ãå
æ©ãããšç°äžããã¯é
åžNGãããšã©ãã©ãNGã®ã客æ§ãå¢ããæ¥ã«æ¥ã«å
æ©ããã¯å±
å Žæããªãããã
æ¯åããã®ãã©ããŒã§å
¥ããŠããã颚åãã€ãã«å
¥ããªããªã£ãŠããŸãããã¡ãã«ããã€ãµãŒãã¹ã§å
¥æµŽãããŠãã ããããšãªãŒããŒããããã®ã®ã粟ç¥ç§å®ç¿ãæãåºãããå
æ¯ã ã£ãã
case12ã§ãèšèŒããããã¢ã«ããã€ããŒã®æ¹ã¯é¡ã®èšéåãç©åã匷ãããªã®ã§åºæ¬1床ã2床倱æãããšãããã€ã¯æµïŒããšèªèããã
ã颚åä»å©ã«å
¥ã£ãè¥ãã¹ã¿ããã¯2ååã¿ã€ãããã颚åNGã«ãªããããã©ã³ã®ãã°ã¡ããã§ããåãŸãããã«ãªãåã£çµã¿åãã«ãªã£ãã
å
æ©ããã¯ãŸããŸãè¥ãããå
ãã«ããŒã ãã©ã£ããåºãã®ãåãããªãçæ§ã®åããåã§ãã°ã¡ããã¹ã¿ããã®éŠãçµããã®ã§ãæµç³ã®ããããæ¢ããã
ãã£ããã®ïŒåæ¢ããè¡çºãããããæµãšèªèãã圌女ã¯ããããè¬ã¯æåŠã殎ãæãããä»ã®ã客æ§ãšåã£ãŠãããšå€§å¥œããªãã©ã€ããŒã®åçãè¿ããšè¹Žããå
¥ããŠããã
ãã®ããããŸããããããããã®æã¯ãŸã ããã®åžžå€ãããªããã§ããã©ãšçªã£èŸŒã¿ããã
å®ã¯ãã¯ãªããã¯ãšã®ããã«ã¯ãŒã¯ã§åããŠãããã€ãµãŒãã¹ãªã®ã§ããã ã®åçºãã€ããªã®ã«æ¯é±æ¥ææ¥ã«æ¥ãããèŠããããŠããã蹎ããããåŸãã¯ãããã®ã ã
ããŸãã客æ§ãšé¢ãããªãçžè«å¡ããã¯ãããªããäœãã£ããã§ããïŒããšäžå¯©ããããããäœãããŠããªãã
ããããéŠç· ããããŠããžã§ãã¡ããã£ãŠãããã°ã¡ãããå©ãããã§ãããèŠãŠãããïŒããªãããã®æãã®å Žã«ããŸããããïŒïŒãšèšããããªã£ãã
çµå±ãããããæ¥ææ¥å
æ©ããã«é¢ãã£ãŠãè¬ã飲ãŸããããšãåºæ¥ãªãã®ã§ãæ¯åºŠçžè«å¡ã«é Œãã ã
è¡å§ãã²ã©ããšæž¬ããªãããããè¡å§ã¯å¥ã®æŽŸé£çè·åž«ã§ãå³ããããã§ã圌女ã倧奜ããªãã©ã€ããŒããã«æž¬ã£ãŠãããããšãå€ãã£ãïŒæéŠã«å·»ãã ããªãã§âŠâŠïŒ
ãããèªåã®ä»äºãåºæ¥ãªããŠæ
ããªãããªãã§åœŒå¥³ãšããäžæãè¡ããªããã ãããããããããã€ãã§è¡ã£ãŠãã®ã«ç¡èœæ±ãããããããã
æ¯é±æ¥ææ¥ãè¿æã«ãããã®ãã€ãµãŒãã¹åéã¯æ¬åœã«æé£ãã£ãããå
æ©ãã以å€ã®æ¹ãšã¯å
šãåé¡ãªãä»äºãããŠããããªã®ã§ãç¹ã«æå¥ãèšãããããšããªãã£ãã®ã ãããšããæ¥ã
ãæ°ã«å
¥ãã®ãã©ã€ããŒããããäŒã¿ã§ãåœŒå¥³ã¯æããããŒãã¢ããããŠããã
2人ã®ã客æ§ãšæ®Žãæããå¢ãã§å§å©ã
ãåããã¡ããããããã ãïŒã
ã¯ãïŒïŒäœã ã£ãŠãŠãŠãŠãŠãŠïŒïŒïŒèšèªã«ãéå®³ãæ¥ãŠããã®ã§ã圌女ã¯äžæè°ãªèšèã話ãïŒïœ£
ãã»ãã¿ãããŸãå€ãªããšèšã£ãŠããæ°æã¡æªãïŒã
ãæªãã£ãŠãã£ãïŒæªãã£ãŠãã£ããªãããããïŒïŒã
ããã§æåã«æå¥ãèšã£ãAããã®éŠããããå
æ©ãããããã¢ã«ããã®ã¯ããããšãäºåæã«ããçžè«å¡ãããªãã ç§ã«ããªãäœãã£ããã§ããïŒãšèšã£ãŠãããã®å¥³ã¯é¢åäºã¯çµ¶å¯Ÿã«é¢ãããªãã®ã§åããªãã
ãããããã°ããšæã£ããããã¯æ®éã«è¿ã¥ããŠå
æ©ãããåŒãé¢ããããããšçå
ã¯åœç¶ç§ã«ããããããã®é ããã³ãã³æ®Žã£ãŠããŠãèäžã«äŒžã³ãŸãã£ãçªãããŠãŠããããããã£ãŠãããããªãããã¡ãã¯æµæã§ããªããã ãã
è
ã¯åŒã£æ»ããŠããããåã©ããæŽãããããã¿ããæªããçžæã¯å
ãã«ããŒã ãç¡é§ã«ãã¯ãŒã¯åŒ·ãã
ãå
æ©ãããæŽåã¯ãã¡ãããªãã§ããã
ãããããïŒããŸãå«ãã ïŒã·ãã·ãã·ãã·ãã·ãïŒã
ããããã¯ãŒãã¯ãããã ãªãããšæ
ããªãæ°æã¡ã«ãªãããµãšé æ¹ãŸã§æ¯ã®çºã«è·å Žãšä»è·ãåŸåŸ©ããæ¯åã®ããšãæã£ãã
ããŸãã«ãããŒãã¢ããããŠã©ããããããªãæã§ç©åãããæ¯ãã€ããŠåºãŠããçžè«å¡ãããã§äœãããã§ããªãããã£ãšäºåæã«é£ããŠãããä»ã®ã客ãããšé¢ããšãã察å¿ãåã£ãŠããããæåã£ããããããããšå¿ã®äžã§ãŒããã
ãããã¯ãã®äººã®æ¯åãå¯åæ³ã ãªããŠçµ¶å¯Ÿã«èšããªããæããªãã
圌女ã¯ãæ¬åœã«ãã¡ãããããããªãããã倧å€ã ã£ãã
ãªãã§ãããŸã§å¯Ÿå¿ããŠå
šåŠå®ãããªãããããã®ïŒãšå
šãŠã«ãããŠçªã£èŸŒã¿ãããªãããããŠæªãã®ã¯åœŒå¥³ãåŒãåããã¢ããªè·å Žäžé·ã§ãããéã®ããšããèããŠããªãäŒç€Ÿãæªãã
ãã€ã§åŒãåããã¬ãã«ãããã¯ããªã®ã«ãããã察å¿ããã¹ã¿ããã®ããªããã®å Žæã§åŒãåããã®ã¯ãšãŠãç¡çã ã£ãã
倱çŠããæã¯3人ãããã§ãªããã³äº€æãã颚åã¯æåŸã«3人ãããã§ç¡çããããç¶æ
ãããããããïŒãããããïŒãããããæ®ºããã³ãã³ãã³ãã³ãã³ãã³ãïŒïŒïŒã
ãšããæ°å³ã®æªãåªæã®ãããªåå®ã颚åå ŽããèãããŠããã®ã ã
ããã¯èªç¥çãã€ãµãŒãã¹ã§ã¯ãªãã1éšã®äººéã¯ç
ãã£ãŠãããããªå€ãªäººãå±
ããã€ãµãŒãã¹ã«è¡ã£ãŠããªããŠè¿æã®äººã«èšãããããªãããš5åã»ã©äžææããäŒã¿ããšãã圢ã§èŸããããã
æªããã©ããªãã§ãããªã«å€§å€ãªäººããã€ãµãŒãã¹ã§é¢åã¿ãŠããã ïŒ
å®¶æã®ä»è·è² æ
軜æžãªãæœèšãããããã€ãµãŒãã¹ã¯æŽ»åãããå Žæã§ãå
šãŠã¬ã¹ãã€ãç®çã§æ¯æ¥æ¥ãããããã£ã¡ãããã©ããã
çå·ã¯å¢ããäžæ¹ãªã®ã«ãäŒç€ŸåŽããäœãèšãããããã¿æ¶ãããã確ãã«å¥çŽæ¡ä»¶ïŒã«ã¯ããããèªç¥çã®æ¹ãšå¯Ÿå¿ããæªæäºã
ã¯æžããŠããªãããåŽçœã«ããªããªãã
æ¯åºŠæ¯åºŠçå·ãå¢ãããããªãã®ã§ãæ¥ææ¥åºå®ã§ä»äºãããŠããã£ãŠãããèŸãããããªããšæãå¥ã®å Žæãæ¢ããããæ¥ææ¥å¶æ¥ããŠãããã€ãµãŒãã¹ãšãããã®ãããŸãè¿æã«ã¯ãªãããéã®çºã«ä»æ¹ãªãåããã
æé£ãããšã«ãäŒç€ŸåŽãçè§£ã瀺ããã®ããç§ãå
æ©ããã«é¢ãããªããŠãè¯ãããšã«ãªããããå§å©ã«ãªã£ãŠãããã¹ã¿ãããåŒã¹ãšèšãããã
ããããããªãã ãã©ããã®äŒç€ŸãåŒã³ããæã«èª°ãå±
ãªããã ãã
ããã«ãããœã³ã³ãš8æéã«ããã£ãããŠããã®çžè«å¡ãäœåãåŒãã§ãã®ã«ãããã¢ã«åºãŠããããšãªããŠä»ãŸã§1床ããªããã
ãã«ãã«ããããªãã§ç§ããã©ãã«èµ·ãããæ±ãã«ãªã£ãŠãã ãããµããããªã
é¢ãããªããŠããã£ãŠèšãããç¡èŠãä»ã®ã客æ§ãšå§å©ããŠããå
æ¯ã¯ããã£ã¡ã
ãç®ã«å
¥ã£ãããé¢ãããªãšèšããããŸãŸè¡åããã
ããããä»åºŠã¯ããªãã§ã客æ§åå£«ã§æããŠãã®ã«æ¢ããŠãããªããã§ããïŒããšæå¥ãèšãããã
ãããã«ççŸããèšãæ¹ã«ã¯ããœè
¹ãç«ã£ãã®ã§ããã€ãã ãã©ãã以åäžåé¢ãããªããŠãããšèšãããã®ã§äœãããŠãããŸãããå
çšåŒã³ãŸãããã©ã颚åå ŽåŽã¯ã¹ã¿ãããå¿ãããŠåããŸããããããããïŒçžè«å¡ïŒããããŸããããïŒããšèšã£ãã
å®éãããã¢ã¯ãããã ãã颚åã«3人ãä»ã¯éè¿ã§äžåšãããšã¯äºåæã«çžè«å¡ã ãã ã
ã¡ãã£ãšé·ãã®ã§åœŒå¥³ãç§»åããå
ããã®2ãž