
ã5幎ã®éå©å·®ãéèŠâšãæ¡å€§ãç¶ããæ¥ç±³éå©å·®ãšå éãç¶ããåå®ãã¬ã³ãðŽïŒæ¥çµæ°è解説ð 2023/09/22
æ¥æ¬çµæžæ°èã®èšäºã§
泚ç®ãããå
容ããããŸããã®ã§
èšäºã«ããããšæããŸãð
é·ãã§ãããç®æ¬¡ããæŽ»çšããã ããŸããŠ
ã©ããæåŸãŸã§ã芧ãã ããïŒ
åãæ¥ç±³ïŒå¹Žéå©å·®ã«é£åãéèæ¿çã®éãæ ãïŒããžã·ã§ã³ïŒ
ãå€åœçºæ¿åžå Žã§åå®ã»ãã«é«ãé²ããç±³é£éŠæºåçäºäŒïŒïŒŠïŒ²ïŒ¢ïŒãæ¿çéå©ãé«ãæ°Žæºã«æ®ã眮ãäžæ¹ãæ¥éã®ç·©åé·æåã§æ¥ç±³éå©å·®ã®æ¡å€§ãç¶ããšã®èŠæ¹ãæ ¹åŒ·ãã®ãèæ¯ã ãæ¥ç±³éå©å·®ãšãããšïŒïŒå¹Žåµå©åãã®å·®ã泚ç®ãããã¡ã ããä»ã®åçžå Žã®èŠæ¥µãã«ã¯ïŒå¹Žã®éå©å·®ãéèŠãšã®å£°ãããã
ãïŒïŒæ¥ã®æ±äº¬åžå Žã§åã¯ïŒãã«ïŒïŒïŒïŒåïŒïŒéè¿èŸºãšæšå¹ŽïŒïŒæä»¥æ¥ã®å®å€ãã€ãããã¯ïŒïŒæ¥ãŸã§éããç±³é£éŠå ¬éåžå Žå§å¡äŒïŒïŒŠïŒ¯ïŒïŒ£ïŒåŸã«ç€ºããåå è ã®æ¿çéå©èŠéãã§ãïŒïŒïŒïŒå¹Žæ«ã®äºæ³ãäžæ¹ä¿®æ£ãããå ¬è¡šåŸããéèåŒãç· ãã«ååããªãã¿ã«æŽŸããšã®åãæ¢ãããå売ãã»ãã«è²·ããåºãã
ãåçžå Žãšã®é£åæ§ãé«ããšããããæ¥ç±³éå©å·®ã ããçæããè¶ é·æãŸã§æ§ã ã ãåçžå Žãå ãäžã§éèŠãªã®ã¯ã©ã®å¹Žéã®éå©å·®ã ãããã
ãïŒå¹Žéå©ã¯ãã€ãŒã«ãã«ãŒãïŒå©åãæ²ç·ïŒã®èµ·ç¹ã§ããçæã®æ¿çéå©ã«è¿ããåäžå€®éè¡ã«ããéèæ¿çã®åœ±é¿ãåãããããïŒïŒå¹Žéå©ã¯çµæžã®æé·æåŸ ãé·æçãªç©äŸ¡æ å¢ãåæ ããã
ãåçžå Žã®å€åããšæ¥ç±³éå©å·®ã®åããéãããšãçŸç¶ã¯ïŒå¹ŽãšïŒïŒå¹Žã®äžéçãªäœçœ®ã«ããïŒå¹Žã®æ¥ç±³éå©å·®ãšã®é£åæ§ãé«ãããã«ã¿ããã
ãéæèšŒåžã®åŸè€ç¥äºæããŒãçºæ¿ã¹ãã©ããžã¹ãã¯ãïŒïŒå¹Žä»¥éã®åœåµå©åããšåçžå Žã®é¢ä¿ãåæãããšïŒå¹Žã®æ¥ç±³éå©å·®ãå©çšããå Žåãæã説æããããããšèªãã
ãïŒïŒå¹Žã¯çµæžã»ç©äŸ¡æ å¢ãæ ãåºãåé¢ãåœåµã®å¢çºãªã©é絊èŠå ã圱é¿ãããæ¥ç±³äž¡åœã®éèæ¿çã®æ¹åæ§ã®éãã衚ããïŒå¹Žã®éå©å·®ãé©åãšã®èŠæ¹ã ã
ãïŒïŒæ¥ã®ãã¥ãŒãšãŒã¯åžå Žã§ã¯ïŒŠïŒ²ïŒ¢ã®ã¿ã«æŽŸå§¿å¢ãææããã«ç±³ïŒå¹Žåµå©åããäžæ4.58ïŒ å°ã«äžæãç±³éå©äžæã«ããæ¥ç±³ã®ïŒå¹Žéå©å·®ã¯ïŒïŒæ¥æç¹ã§çŽ4.3ïŒ ã«ãŸã§æ¡å€§ããããããåå®ã»ãã«é«ãä¿ããŠããã
ãéæã®åŸè€æ°ã«ãããšãïŒå¹Žã®æ¥ç±³éå©å·®ã«ããšã¥ãåã®é©æ£å€ãæšèšãããš146åã ãšãããå®å¢ã¯ããåå®ã§ãéå©å·®ä»¥äžã«å売ãã®å¢ãã匷ããšããããã ã
ãåŸè€æ°ã¯ãåæ²¹å ç©çžå Žã®äžæã§æ¥æ¬ã®è²¿æåæ¯ãæªåããŠå売ãã匷ãŸããšã®ææããç±³çµæžã®è»çéžæåŸ ãããã«çºæ¿çžå Žã®å€åçäœäžã§ïŒåãåããŠé«éå©ã®ãã«ã§éçšããïŒãåãã£ãªãŒååŒãã®æŽ»çºããéå©å·®ä»¥äžã®åã®æžäŸ¡ã«ã€ãªãã£ãŠããããšã¿ãã
ãæ¥ç±³éå©å·®ãå·¡ã£ãŠã¯ãåºæ¬çã«æéãçãéå©ãæ¯èŒãã¹ãã ããçŸå±é¢ã§ã¯ç±³æ¯æ°ã®è¯å¥œãããã€ãŸã§ç¶ãããèŠæ¥µããããšã®é°å²æ°ãæ ¹åŒ·ããïŒïŒå¹Žã®éå©å·®ãžã®é¢å¿ãé«ããïŒããããéè¡ã®è«žææããŒãã»ããŒã±ããã»ã¹ãã©ããžã¹ãïŒãšã®å£°ãããã
ãç±³ãã§ãã©ã«ãã¡ã³ãïŒïŒŠïŒŠïŒéå©å ç©ãç¹ã蟌ãïŒïŒå¹ŽïŒïŒæã®æ¿çéå©ã¯ãïŒææ«æç¹ã§4.3ïŒ ã ã£ããïŒïŒæ¥ã®ïŒŠïŒ¯ïŒïŒ£ãçµãŠïŒŠïŒ²ïŒ¢ãæ¿çéå©ãé·ãéã髿°Žæºã«æ®ã眮ããšã®èŠæ¹ãåºããã忥æç¹ã§ã¯4.8ïŒ å°ãŸã§äžæããã
ãåžå Žç°å¢æ¬¡ç¬¬ã§ã©ã®æéã®éå©å·®ãžã®é¢å¿ãé«ãŸããã¯å€ããããããã ãæ¥ç±³ã®éå©å·®ã®æ¹åæ§ã«åçãªå€åããªãéããå売ãã»ãã«è²·ãã«åŸæããæè³å®¶ãå€ãç¶æ³ã¯ç¶ãããã ã
ïŒæ¥çµïŒ±ïŒµïŒ©ïŒ£ïŒ«ãã¥ãŒã¹ïŒïŒ®ïŒ±ïŒ®ïŒãç°äžä¿è¡ãç¥å±±çŸèŒïŒ
èšäºã«å¯Ÿããã³ã¡ã³ãð
åçžå Žã¯ç¶èœããŠããŸã
ååŸïŒææç¹ã¯ïŒãã«ïŒïŒïŒïŒåïŒïŒïœïŒïŒéãšã忥ã®åæç¹ã«æ¯ã¹ïŒïŒéã®åå®ã»ãã«é«ã§ãã

ç±³é£éŠå
¬éåžå Žå§å¡äŒïŒïŒŠïŒ¯ïŒïŒ£ïŒã®çµæãåããŠç±³é£éŠæºåçäºäŒïŒïŒŠïŒ²ïŒ¢ïŒã®éèåŒãç· ããé·æåãããšã®èŠæ¹ã匷ãŸã£ããšããããšã§ã
ãããã£ãŠãæ¥ç±³ã®éå©å·®ãæèããå売ãã»ãã«è²·ããåªå¢ã«ãªã£ããšèšããŸã
åžå Žã§ã¯å¿ççç¯ç®ã®ïŒãã«ïŒïŒïŒïŒåãïŒïŒå¹Žå®å€ã®ïŒïŒïŒåïŒïŒéå°ãæèããã€ã€ãããšæãããŸã
ã€ãšã¬ã³ç±³è²¡åé·å®ãæ¥æ¬ã®çºæ¿ä»å
¥ã«ã€ããŠãå€åçïŒãã©ãã£ãªãã£ãŒïŒãæããç®çã§ããã°çè§£ã§ãããšã®ç«å Žã瀺ãããšäŒãã£ãããšã§ãåžå Žã§ã¯æ¿åºã»æ¥éã«ããçºæ¿ä»å
¥ãžã®èŠææã匷ãŸã£ãŠããã®ã§ã
ãã®ãããªãã¥ãŒã¹ãèŠããšããŸããŸãåæ¥è«æãæžãé²ããã¢ãããŒã·ã§ã³ãé«ãŸã£ãŠããŸããð

ææ°ã®ããŒã¿ãçšããããšã¯ã§ããªããããããŸãããã2022幎ã®çºæ¿ä»å ¥ããã£ããåæã§ããããã«åªããŠãããããšæããŸã
ä»åã®åæå¯Ÿè±¡ãšããŠãé©åãªã®ã¯çæçãªçºæ¿ã¬ãŒãã®å€åããã¯ãçµæžå€æ°ã« äžãã圱é¿ãåæãããããçºæ¿ã¬ãŒãã·ã§ãã¯ã«èå¥ã«éããŠã¯ãéå©å¹³äŸ¡èª¬ã«åºã¥ããå®åŒåãçšããããšã§ãããŸãð
ãã®æçš¿ãçºæ¿ã¬ãŒããªãã³ã«ãã¯ãçµæžåŠã«ã€ããŠããçè§£ãæ·±ããããšãã§ããå 容ã«ãªã£ãŠããŸãã®ã§ããã²æåŸãŸã§ã芧ãã ããð
çºæ¿ã¬ãŒãã·ã§ãã¯ã«å¯Ÿãããã¯ãçµæžå€æ°ã®åå¿ð
ãã®æçš¿ã§ã¯ãJorda(2005)ã«ãããããLocal projectionã®ææ³ãçšããŠçºæ¿ã¬ãŒãã·ã§ãã¯ã«å¯Ÿãããã¯ãçµæžå€æ°ã®åå¿ïŒã€ã³ãã«ã¹å¿ç颿°ïŒãæšèšãããšããææ³ã«ã€ããŠã¢ãŠããããããŸãð
ãã®åèè³æã§ã¯ãlogy_{t+h}㯠t æãã h ååæåŸã®ãã¯ãçµæžå€æ°ã®å¯Ÿæ°å€ã衚ããŠããŸã
ãŸãããã¯ãã«Xã«ã¯ãã㯠ãçµæžå€æ° yt ã®ïŒå¯Ÿæ°å€ã®ïŒã©ã°ãããã³çºæ¿ã¬ãŒãã·ã§ã㯠εt^shockã®ã©ã°ãå«ãŸããŠããŸã
æšèšã«çšããæšæ¬ã¯ 1994 幎ãã 2019 幎ãŸã§ã®ååæããŒã¿ã§ãããšè¿°ã¹ãããŠããŸã
泚6ã§èšåãããŠããŸãããããã®ã¢ãã«ã®ã©ã°ã®é·ãã¯BICåºæºã«åŸãã1ïŒããªãã¡ k = 1ïŒãšããŠããããšã確èªããŸã
ãªããã©ã°ã®é·ãã3ã«å€ããå Žåã§ãã以äžã«ç€ºãã€ã³ãã«ã¹å¿ç颿°ã®æšèšçµæå€§ããå€åããªãã£ãããã§ã
ãŸãã³ã³ãããŒã«å€æ°ãšããŠãæ ªäŸ¡ã®å€åçãéèæ¿çã·ã§ã 㯠(Jarocinski and Karadi, 2020) ãå«ããå Žåã§ããã€ã³ãã«ã¹å¿ç颿°ã®æšèšçµæã¯å€§ããã¯å€åããªãããšã倿ããŠããã®ã§ã
以äžã§ã¯ãåèè³æã®æ¬é¡ã§ããçºæ¿ã¬ãŒãã·ã§ãã¯ãäžãããã¯ãçµæžå€æ°ãžã®åœ±é¿ã«ã€ããŠèå¯ããŠãããŸã
詳ããã°ã©ããå³ã¯ããã¡ãã®ãªã³ã¯ããé©å®ã確èªããã ããŸããšå¹žãã§ã
åœå ç·çç£(GDP)ã®åå¿
åèè³æã®å³5ã§ã¯ã1%ã®çºæ¿ã¬ãŒãã·ã§ãã¯ã«å¯Ÿãã GDP ã®åå¿ã瀺ãããŠããŸã
çµè«ã¯ãçºæ¿ã¬ãŒãã«èªåœéè²šãæžäŸ¡ããã·ã§ãã¯ãçãããšãGDP ã¯ã·ã§ãã¯ãçããç¿æããå¢å ããŸã
ãããŠãGDPã®å¢å ã¯2ååæåŸãŸã§ç¶ãããã®å¢å å¹
ã¯10%ã®æžäŸ¡ã·ã§ãã¯ã«å¯ŸããŠ0.5%ã§ãããšèšããŸã
ãããŠã2ååæç®ä»¥éãGDPã¯åŸã
ã«ããšã®æ°Žæºã«æ»ãåããèŠããã·ã§ãã¯ãã2 幎åŸã«ã¯ã·ã§ãã¯åã®æ°Žæºã«æ»ãããšãæç³»ååæããããããŸã
çµ±èšçã«ã¯ææãªå¢å ã§ã¯ãªããã®ã®ãèªåœéè²šãæžäŸ¡ããã·ã§ã㯠ãçããå ŽåãGDPãçæçã«å¢å ãããšããçµæã¯ãäžžå±±ä» (2018) ãæ¥æ¬éè¡(2022)ã§ç€ºãããçµæãšæŽåçã§ãããšèšããã®ã§ã
èšåæè³ã®åå¿
åæ§ã«å³6㯠1%ã®çºæ¿ã¬ãŒãã·ã§ãã¯ã«å¯Ÿããèšåæè³ã®åå¿ã瀺ããŠããŸã
çºæ¿ã¬ãŒãã« èªåœéè²šãæžäŸ¡ããã·ã§ãã¯ãçãããšãèšåæè³ã¯ã·ã§ãã¯ãçããåœæããå¢å ããããšãèŠåããããŸãã
èšåæè³ã®å¢å ã¯ã4ååæåŸãŸã§ç¶ãããã®å¢å å¹
ã¯10%ã®æžäŸ¡ã·ã§ãã¯ã«å¯ŸããŠ1.2%ã§ãããšèšããŸãã
4 ååæç®ä»¥éãèšåæè³ã¯ãã£ãããšããšã®æ°Žæºã«æ»ãåããèŠããã·ã§ãã¯ãã 5 ååæåŸã«ã¯çºæ¿ã¬ãŒãã·ã§ãã¯ã®åœ±é¿ã¯æ¶ããããšãããããŸã
ãªããèªåœéè²šãæžäŸ¡ããã·ã§ãã¯ãçããå Žåãèšåæè³ãææã«å¢å ãããšããçµæã¯ãäŒæ¥éšéã«ãšã£ãŠèªåœéè²šãæžäŸ¡ãã ã·ã§ãã¯ã¯ç·ããŠã¿ããšæ£ã®åœ±é¿ãæã€ããšã瀺åããŠãããšèšããŸãð
ãã®çµæã¯ãèªåœéè²šã®æžäŸ¡ã«ãã£ãŠäŒæ¥ã®èŒžåºãå¢å ããèšåæè³ææ¬²ã匷ãŸãçµæãåæ ãããã®ã§ãããHanagaki and Hori (2015) ã«ããææçãšæŽåçã§ã
æ¬æ¥ã®è§£èª¬ã¯ãããŸã§ãšããŸã
ãã²ãæ¯æ¥ã®ã€ã³ãããã倧åã«
ç¥èã誰ãã®çºã«äœ¿ããç¥æ§ãžãš
å€ããŠãããŸãããð
ãã¬ãžã³ã®ã玹ä»ð
ãã¡ãã«ïŒïŒåãšããŠã®ç§ã®å°±è·æŽ»åäœéšèšããŸãšãããã¬ãžã³ãã玹ä»ãããŠããã ããŸãð
æ§ã
ãªèгç¹ããå°±è·æŽ»åã«ã€ããŠèå¯ããŠããŸãã®ã§ããäžèªããã ããŸããšå¹žãã§ã
æ¹ããŠãå°±è·æŽ»åã¯
æ¬åœã«ããçžãã ãšæããŸããð
ã ããããããçžã倧åã«
ãããŠãéžãã éãæ£è§£ã«ã§ãããã
ãããããåªåããŠãããããªãšæããŸãð¥
ä»åŸãšãäœåãããããé¡ãç³ãäžããŸãð
ãã¡ãã®ãã¬ãžã³ã«ãŠ
ãšãã»ã³ã·ã£ã«çµæžåŠçè«éããªãã³ã«
ãåœéçµæžåŠðãã®åºç€çè«ããŸãšããŠããŸã
ä»åŸãããã«ã³ã³ãã³ããæ¡å
ã§ããããã«åªããŠåããŸã
æåŸãŸã§ãæèªããã ãèª ã«æé£ãããããŸãïŒ
ãããŸã§ãç§ã®èŠè§£ãæã£ãããšã
ãŸãšããããŠããã ããŠãŸãã
ãã®ç¹ã«é¢ããŸããŠããäºæ¿ãã ããð
ãã®æçš¿ãã¿ãŠãã ãã£ãæ¹ã
ã»ãã®å°ããªäºã§ãåŠã³ããã£ãïŒ
èãæ¹ã®åŒãåºããå¢ããïŒ
èªæžããåŠã¹ãããšãå€ãïŒ
ãªã©ãªã©ããã©ã¹ã®åç©«ããã£ãã®ã§ããã°
倧å€å¬ããæããŸãããæçš¿äœæã®å¥å©ã«å°œããŸãïŒïŒ
ãæ°è»œã«ã³ã¡ã³ããããããã¹ããð
ãããŠããå·®ãæ¯ããªããã°
ãã©ããŒïŒã·ã§ã¢ããé¡ããããã§ãð
ä»åŸãšãäœåãããããé¡ãããããŸãïŒ