
æãéãĒãåąæŠ
荺č
ãŗãĄãŗãīŧ
ãįŦŦīŧįĢ ãããįŽæããšãææãŽããæšãčĒãããžããæŦį¯ã§ã¯ããããžã§æŦæ¸ã§čŋ°ãšãĻãããã¨ãäŧįˇååããããæ˛čĻŗįãĒæĨŊčĻŗčĢãããããããŽæãæĨããã¨ããéãæĨŊčĻŗčĢãåŽŖč¨ãããžãã
ã荺č
čĒčēĢãŽįãįĢãĄããäŧį¤žåĄįæ´ģããããĻéä¸åŊäŊé¨ããåžãį´æã¨å
ąéŗ´ããããŽãå¤ããããããã¯åäžãŽé ãĢåŖéčĻãåŽäŋéäēãã大äēēããĄãåĻåŽãé ããã¨ããããããŧãŽįãæšã¨ãéããããžį°čãĢäŊããã¨ãé¸ãŗãããæåŗã§äģäēēãŽįæ´ģãįŽæããĻãããã¨ããį§ãŽäēēįãŽäŧįˇååã§ããã¨ããįĸēäŋĄãåžæŧãããĻãããžãã
īŧãčĒãŋä¸ããīŧ荺č
ãããŽãįĨããīŧ
įŦŦīŧįĢ īŧååä¸ãŽæäģŖ
7.1 æãéãĒãåąæŠ
į§ããĄãŽå°įãčĻãããĻããåąæŠãŽãŠãããįåŖãĢį įŠļããĻããäēēã ãĢã¨ãŖãĻãį§ããĄãŽéåŊãįĩļæįãĒãã¨ãĢįããŽäŊå°ã¯ãããžããããģãŧįĸēåŽãĒãŽã¯ãæŋæ˛ģãéčãã¨ããĢãŽãŧãæč˛ãåģįããããĻæãéčĻãĒįæ įŗģãããŋããĒå´ŠåŖãĢåããŖãĻãããã¨ã§ããæŦæ¸ãŽåˇįãĢč˛ģãããååš´éã§ãį§ã¯ããããææãŽåąæŠãä¸ã¤ä¸ã¤č¯ãįč§ŖãããããĢãĒããããŽåˇ¨å¤§ãã¨åŋ įļæ§ãããį¨åēĻãžã§įč§Ŗã§ãããããĢãĒããžãããæ¯åš´ããŽä¸åš´ãį§ããĄãŽæäģŖã§æåžãŽãæŽéããŽåš´ãĢãĒããŽã§ã¯ãĒããã¨čããĻããžãããå´ŠåŖãããããããŽãŽææãæãããããåéŋããããæåãŽåĒåãããã¨ããã§ãį§ããĄãį ´åąã¸ã¨é§ãįĢãĻãåãĢã¯æĩããĒããã¨ãįĨãŖãĻãį§ã¯įĩļæããžããã
æŦæ¸ãŽä¸ģãĒįŽįãŽä¸ã¤ã¯ãããŽįĩļæãĢčĒãããããã¨ã§ããããŽįã¨ããĻį§ãæį¤ēãããŽã¯ãįãĢéŠãŖãĻããĒããčǰã˛ã¨ãæŗåããĒããŖããããĒæĨŊčĻŗčĢã§ããããã¯į§ããĄãį´éĸããåąæŠãŽå¤§ãããįĄčĻããį˛įŽįãĒæĨŊčĻŗčĢã§ã¯ãĒããããŽä¸įãŽéãäēåŽãŽå ¨ãĻãĢįŽãåããĻåãčžŧãã åŽčˇĩįãĒæĨŊčĻŗčĢãĒãŽã§ããããŽæĨŊčĻŗčĢãæˇąãčĒčããĻããææã¨čĻããŋã¯ãææã¨åããããæããåå¨ããåąæŠãŽéįĩãįŽåãĢčŋĢãä¸ã§įãããæéĢæŊŽãĢčŋãĨãã¤ã¤ãããžãã
äŊããããžããį§ãčĒčããĻãããŽã¯į°åĸåąæŠã§ããæ°åå¤åãį æŧ åããĩãŗã´ãŽįŊåãæ¨šæ¨ãŽæ¯æģã襨åãŽæĩå¤ąã῝å°ãŽį ´åŖãįįŠå¤æ§æ§ãŽå垊ä¸čŊãĒåĒå¤ąãææ¯åģæŖįŠãæžå°æ§åģæŖįŠãå ¨ãĻãŽįįŠį´°čãĢčįŠããPCBãæļæģ ãã¤ã¤ããåē大ãĒįąå¸¯é¨æãæģæģ ããåˇãæšãæĩˇãããŋåąąã¨æĄįŗå ´ãįããä¸įãččŖ ã§åēãããåŠįãĢčŊã¨ãčžŧãžããå§ŋã
į§ãčĒčããĻãããŽã¯ãããŧã¯ãĒã¤ãĢãŽãã¨ããããĻįĩæ¸ã¤ãŗããŠãéŖįŗ§äžįĩĻãŽããããéĸãåįŗįæãĢäžåããĻãããã¨ã§ãããžãį§ã¯ãåžæĨããįĨãããĻããäģŖæŋã¨ããĢãŽãŧæēãããããĢã§ãįŗæ˛šããŦãšãĢåãŖãĻäģŖãããŽã¯æããĒãã¨įč§ŖããĻããžãã
į§ãčĒčããĻãããŽã¯čŋĢãæĨãåĨåēˇåąæŠã§ããčĒåˇąå įĢįžæŖãŽæĨåĸã¨ãééåąä¸æ¯ãéģįŖæŗĸãģååĻįŠčŗĒãģéēäŧåæąæãŽåå ã¨ãããããããåŊąéŋã§ãããžãį§ã¯ãéåããįžäģŖãŽéŖįæ´ģãããģã¨ããŠãŽåģčŦåãĢã¯æ¯æ§ãããåšæãįĄããã¨ãäģŖæŋåģįãĢ寞ããæå§ãŽãã¨ãįč§ŖããĻããžãã
į§ãčĒčããĻãããŽã¯ãä¸įéčãˇãšãã ãŽčåŧąæ§ã500åš´åããįļãããēãčŦīŧåēčŗéčŠæŦēīŧããããĻãĸãĄãĒãĢãŽåĩåããŠããããįļæã§ããĒããĒãã°ããĄãžãĄčĩˇãããã¤ããŧã¤ãŗããŦã¨éč˛¨å´ŠåŖã¨ææ ãŽãã¨ã§ãã
į§ãįĨãŖãĻãããŽã¯ãããĄãˇãēã ãįŖčĻåŊåŽļã¸ã¨åããæŋæ˛ģãŽåžåãæåŗäģ¤ãŽįēåã¨ããįŽįãé ããããĒãᎿĨæå¯žåŋč¨įģããĄããŖãĸãŽä¸æĨĩéä¸ããããĻį¤žäŧå ¨äŊãĢæĩ¸éããĻããæŋåēåŽŖäŧįĩįšãŽãã¨ã§ããããžããĢã䏿ãčĄãŖãĻãããŽã§ãįĩįšãŽčˇåĄã§ããããŽæåŗãĢæ°äģããĻããããä¸įã§æãéæĻčŖ ããåŊãĢãããĻãåŠįãŽãããŽæŋåēäšãŖåããæŖåŊåããĻããžããžããį§ãįĨãŖãĻãããŽã¯ãä¸įãŽãã¯ãŧã¨ãĒãŧããŽįįĨãæĻå¨ãģéēģčŦãģååæįŖæĨã¸ãŽäžåããããĻãįŠäēãããŠããŠãĢãĒãããĢã¤ããĻæ¨ŠåãĢãããŋäģããã¨ã¸ãŽįĩļæãéĢãžãŖãĻãããã¨ã§ã[荺č¨ģ1]ããžãå°æ°ãŽč ãŖããĒãŗã´ãåãé¤ããã¨ã§ãˇãšãã ãæĩåã§ããã¨ãæããžããããããã¯į§ããĄãŽææãŽéčĻãĒæŠéĸããģãŧå ¨ãĻããŽįĨåĨĒãĢå æ ããĻãããã¨ãįč§ŖããĻããããã§ãã
į§ãįĨãŖãĻãããŽã¯ãææãĢéˇãéã¤ããžã¨ãŖãĻããčĄįčãææãäģæĨã§ãæŦčŗĒįãĢ襰ããĻããĒããã¨ã§ããį§ãŽæĨŊčĻŗčĢã¯ãããæãŽčĩ¤ãåãæ¯čĻĒãŽįŽãŽåã§åŖãĢåŠãã¤ããããĻæģãã§ãããŽããįĄčĻããããŽã§ã¯ãããžãããæ´å˛ãŽä¸ã§įš°ãčŋãããįĩãããŽčĻããĒã大éčæŽēããįĄčĻããããŽã§ã¯ãããžããããžããį§ãŽåŊãåĢããä¸įä¸ãŽååæãčĻå¯įŊ˛ã§åēãčĄãããĻããæˇåããįĄčĻããããŽã§ããããžããã
į§ãŽæĨŊčĻŗčĢã§čĒčããĻãããŽã¯ãä¸įãŽč¨čĒã¨æåã¨ãŗããĨãããŖããå ¨ä¸įãåčŗĒåããäŧæĨã¨æļč˛ģč ãĢããŖãĻį ´åŖããįļããĻãããã¨ã§ããį§ãįĨãŖãĻãããŽã¯ãįŦŦä¸ä¸įãŽåˇĨå ´ã§ãŽå´åæĄäģļãããããĢčåģļããå°įĒŽã¨įĩļæãŽãã¨ã§ããį§ãäŧãŖãå´åč ããĄã¯äŊã¨ãįæ´ģãããããĢéą80æéåããããŽãããã§å é˛åŊã¯äŊãŽåŊšãĢãįĢããĒãããŠãšããã¯ãŽãŦãŠã¯ãŋãŽåąąãĢåãããĻįĒæ¯ã§ãããŽã§ãã
į§ãįĨãŖãĻãããŽã¯ãįžå¨ãŽã°ããŧããĢäŊåļä¸ã§æãæĩãžããåč ã§ãããåŽéãĢã¯æãåããĒį į˛č ãŽä¸äēēã ã¨ãããã¨ã§ããį§ãįŽãŽåŊãããĢããĻãããŽã¯ã大éæãĄãŽį夿ã¨įĩļæã¨å¤įŦã§ããčąĒé¸ããéããšããŧããĢãŧãčŗįŖãååŖ°ãæ¨ŠåããããæãĢå Ĩããã¨ããã§ãåŋãŽééãåãããã¨ã¯ã§ããĒããŽã§ãã
į§ãæãčžåŖãĒæĨé˛ä¸ģįžŠč ã¨åããããĢčĒčããĻãããŽã¯ãį§ããĄãŽåĻæ ĄãååæãŽãããĢãĒãŖãĻãããã¨ã§ããæåēéįˇãŽããĒãąãŧããéåąæĸįĨæŠããããĢãŧãŽæãæãĄæ¤æģãåļæãį§įŠãŽææįĻæĸãčŦįŠæ¤æģãæĻčŖ čĻååĄãį§æčĻåŽããããĒįŖčĻãæåžããĒãč ã¸ãŽåģčŦãĢããæåļãĒãŠãæãŖãĻããå ´åããããžããį§ãįĨãŖãĻããčĻĒããĄãŽä¸ãĢã¯ãåäžãĢčŦãéŖ˛ãžããĒããŖããã¨ã§æŗįææŽĩãĢ訴ããã¨č ãããäēēã ãããžãã
į§ãŽæĨŊčĻŗčĢã¯ããã¯ããã¸ãŧã¨ããįĨãį§ããĄãæããããĢããŖãĻæĨããŽãé ŧããĢããĻããããã§ããããžããããĒããĒãããã¯ããã¸ãŧãå°įãčåģãããįæ´ģãŽããŧãšãå éãããä¸įããéã貥įŖãããŧãŋãĢ夿ãéäēēéįãĒããŽãĢããĻããã¨ãį§ã¯čĒčããĻããããã§ãã
ã§ããããį§ããã åąæŠãŽæŦåŊãŽæ§į¸ãčĒčããĻããĒãããæĨŊčĻŗä¸ģįžŠč ãĒãŽã ã¨ã¯æããĒãã§ãã ãããį§ã¯ããŽå ¨ãĻãåãčžŧãŋãĒããããæĨŊčĻŗä¸ģįžŠč ã§ããįļããĻããžããåãæĨŊčĻŗčĢã§ããįžå¨å¤ããŽäēēã ãå°įãĢäŊãŋãĒããããããĢå°įãäŊãåēããĻããã¨ããäēåŽãčģŊã ããįĄčĻãããŽã¯ãæĨŊčĻŗčĢã§ãäŊã§ããĒãåãĒãįŠēæŗãĢéããžãããããã¯ãææ¯åģæŖįŠåĻįå ´ããĸãšããĄãĢãččŖ ããĻããããĢé§čģå ´äģĨå¤ãŽäŊããããŖããã¨ãåŋããĻããžããããĒæĨŊčĻŗčĢã§ããčĻããĻããĒããã°ãæ°ãĢãããã¨ãĒãŠįĄããŽã§ãã
é§čģå ´ãŽæ¯åŠãį¤ēããããĢãããŽį¨ŽãŽčǤãŖãæĨŊčĻŗčĢã¯ããã¤ã¯įŊããŽå ã§ããį§ãŽæĨŊčĻŗčĢã¯ãæčĄį寞įãŽčĢįã¨ã¯åĨãŽããŽã§ããæčĄį寞įããããŽã¯ãããŽãããĒé ãããåéĄã¯å¤§ããĻéčĻã§ã¯ãĒããæįĩįãĢã¯į§åĻãįããčĻã¤ãããã¯ããã¸ãŧãæšæŗãčĻã¤ããĻãããã¨ãããã¨ã§ããåž ãĄæãã ãã¯ããã¸ãŧãŽįæŗéˇããžããžãæĒæĨã¸ã¨é ãããŖãĻããäģãį§ããĄãŽå¤ãã¯ããŽãã¨ãčĻæããĻãããŽã§ã¯ãĒãã§ããããã
ããã§ãŽį§ãŽįŽįã¯ãį§ããĄãæŦåŊãĢãį°åĸã貥æŋãæŋæ˛ģãã¨ããĢãŽãŧãååŖãåģįãæ°´ãŽåąæŠãĢį´éĸããĻãããã¨ããããĒããĢčĒŦããã¨ã§ã¯ãããžãããäģãŽäēēããĄãį§ãããã¯ãããĢčĒŦåžåãŽããčĒŦæãããĻããžãããžããããŽãããĒäēæ ãéŋãããããããããĒãã¨ãã叿ãããĒããĢæąããããã¨ãįŽįã§ããããžãããåąæŠã¯éŋããããžããããĒããĒããåąæŠãéŋãããããĢčĩˇãããšããã¨ã¯ãããŽįĩæã¨ããĻããčĩˇããĒãããã§ããį ´įļģãåéŋãããããĢé莝ãå¤ããææĄã¯ãäģãŽã¨ããå ¨ãĻčåįĄį¨Ŋã§éįžåŽįã§ããį§ãæĨŊčĻŗčĢãã¨ããŽã¯ãį§ããĄãéåŖã¨ããĻčŊãĄãã¨ãããžã§čŊãĄãã¨ãããįžåŽįãĒãã¨ããå¯čŊãĒãã¨ããŽåŽįžŠããããĢãå¤ããã¨įĨãŖãĻããããã§ãã
åĨãŽč¨ãæšããããĒããį§ãŽæĨŊčĻŗčĢã¯åĨ补ãĢãããŖãĻãããŽã§ããčļ čĒįļįãĒäģ˛äģč ãį§ããĄãæããĢæĨããŽã§ã¯ãããžãããåĨ补ã¨ã¯äŊã§ãããīŧ åĨ补ã¯ãäŊãå¯čŊãĒãŽãã¨ããæ°ããĒæčĻããįãžãããŽã§ãããäēēįãįŽĄįããŗãŗãããŧãĢãããã¨ããčŠĻãŋãæžæŖãããã¨ããįãžãããŽã§ããåäēēãŽäŊé¨ã§ã¯ãäēēįãĢæãĄãŽããããã¨ããĢåĨ补ãčĩˇãããã¨ãå¤ãããŽã§ãããĸãĢãŗãŧãĢäžåč ãĢã¨ãŖãĻããé ããããã°ãããã¨ããææĄã¯éĻŦéšŋéĻŦéšŋãããä¸å¯čŊã§ãæŗåãã§ããĒããã¨ã§ããåĨ补ãåŋ čĻãĒãŽã§ããããã¨åãå¤åãå°įãæããããĢåŋ čĻãĒãŽã§ãããããææĄããä¸ģæĩæ´žãŽæŋæ˛ģåŽļã¯čǰãããããããŽå¤åããŠããģãŠæˇąãããŽã§ãããã¨ãåŋ čĻããåããŖãĻããäēēããģã¨ããŠããžããã
å ãĢčŋ°ãšãåąæŠãæãéãĒãã¨ããäēæ ãåļåžĄä¸čŊã§ãããã¨ãįæãåĻåŽã§ããĒããĒãã¨ããæ§äŊåļãŽå¤ąæãåŽå ¨ãĢæãããĢãĒãã¨ããäģã¯įĩļæįãĒãģãŠæĨé˛įãĢčĻããč§ŖæąēįãåŊããåãŽãã¨ãĢãĒãã§ãããã
ãããĻãããã¯åŋ ãčĩˇããžãããããããŽåąæŠããã¤čĩˇãããã¯åãããžããããåąæŠãé§ãįĢãĻãåã¯åŽščĩĻãĒãããŽã§ãããé ããæŠããå§ŋãįžããŽã¯ééããããžãããã¯ããæãĢåãåēããæĩããč¨įįšãčļ ããĻå éããį§ããĄã¯ããŽåŊąéŋãåŗããå§ããã°ããã§ããäģŽãĢäģãį§ããĄãæ°ããĒæąæããŠããĢãéŖãæĸããã¨ããĻããæĸãĢčĩˇããĻããžãŖãįæ įŗģãŽæåˇã¯į ´åąãåŧãčĩˇãããŽãĢååãĒãģãŠčįŠãããĻããžããåãåŋ įļæ§ããå ŦčĄčĄįãæč˛ãéčãæŋæ˛ģãĒãŠãäģãŽé åãĢãåŊãĻã¯ãžããžããããæé ããĒãŽã§ãããŠããģãŠæŠãããŠããģãŠæĒãããŠããģãŠéˇãįļããã ããŽåéĄãĒãŽã§ããããĒãããŠããĒãĢæĒãäēæ ãæŗåããĻããããããããŖã¨æĒããã¨ãĢãĒããžããį§ãŽč¨ããã¨ãäŋĄããããĒããĒãããæ¯ãããæ¨ã ãããæ˛¸įšãã¨ããŖãæŦãčĒãã§ãã ãã[荺č¨ģ2]ã
ãŋã¤ãŋããã¯åˇãŽãããĢããã¯ããã¸ãŧį¤žäŧãŽåĸãã¯ããžããĢåŧˇå¤§ãĒãŽã§ããã¨ãäģã¨ãŗã¸ãŗãéčģĸããæŋããčĩãåãŖãã¨ããã§ãįæįãģ䏿įãĒįŠäēãŽæĩãã¯å¤§ããĻå¤ãããĒãã§ãããããã¯ãéŋããããĒãčĒįļã¨ãŽčĄįĒãĢåããŖãĻãį§ããĄã¯ãžãŖããããĢé˛ãã§ããžããããããį§ããĄã¯čŋĢãããæ°ˇåąąãéŋããããããŦãŧããããããčĩãåãŖãããããã¨ãĒãŠãģã¨ããŠįĄããŖãã°ãããããå ¨éåé˛ãã¨ããįĄéĸåŋãĒæšéãåãįļããĻããžãããįąŗåŊã§ã¯ãå ąåå ãŽæšéã¯åēæŦįãĢãæ°ˇåąąãŖãĻäŊã īŧãã¨ããããŽã§ãããããŖãŊãæ°ä¸ģå ã¯éčˇ¯ãæ°åēĻã ãå¤ãããã¨ããĻããžãããä¸įčšåޤãŽéŖ˛ãŋįŠãããŧããģãŠæŠãčĩãåããã¨ã¯ãããžãããæ¤č¨ãããĻãããįžåŽįããĒææĄãåŽčĄå¯čŊãĒåĻĨåæĄã¯æĨĩããĻä¸ååã§ããäēŦéŊč°åŽæ¸ã䏿šãŽæŋå ã¯åĻåŽãããã䏿šãŽæŋå ã¯æ¯æããžããããããããé ããįãããã¨åããŖãĻããäēēã¯ãģã¨ããŠããžãããįąŗåŊãŽå¤ã§ã¯ãã¤ãŗããä¸åŊãŽãããĒãįēåąéä¸åŊããæŦ§įąŗãŽæŠéĸæčŗåŽļãĢåžæŧããããĒãããæĄæãģå åˇĨãģæļč˛ģãģåģæŖã¨ããæ§æĨãŽį´įˇãĸããĢãĢåžãŖãĻãããããããĒåˇĨæĨåã¨ããįŗįããŋã¤ãŋããã¯åˇãŽãã¤ãŠãŧãĢæãå ĨããĻããžãã
ããŽä¸æšãčšåޤã§ã¯ããŧããŖãŧãįļããĻããĻãããŽéãĢãæåãŽæ°ˇãŽį ãæŖãéŗãčšå ãĢéŋãæ¸Ąããåããæĩˇæ°´ãŽåĨæĩãéåŖãæŦĄã ã¨äšãčļããĻããŖãåžã§ãããããŧããŖãŧã¯įļããžããæä¸éãŽį˛æŋã§ã¯æĨŊåŖãæŧåĨãįļããčšã¯åžããĻãããžãããåšŗå¸¸ã¨ããåšģæŗãįļæãããã¨åŊãæ¨ãĻãĻįĩļæįãĒåĒåãįļããžãã
ããŽæįšã§ãįĢļäēãåŽå ¨åŽåŋãįĩæ¸įčĒįĢã¨ããäŧãĻãŽåŽå ¨ãĒį ´įļģã¯įĢãčĻããããæãããĢãĒãå§ããčǰãįĄčĻã§ããĒããĒããžããäģĨåãĢčĒãã æ˛čĻŗįãĒãã¸ããšæ¸ãä翏ŦããĻãããŽã¯ã䏿šãĢã¯į¯įŊĒãčåģļãããšãŠã čĄããã䏿šãĢã¯åĄãĢå˛ãžããã˛ãŧããč¨įŊŽããããã§ãŗãšã§å˛ãžããčĻå ąæŠãč¨įŊŽãããčĻååĄãé įŊŽãããčŖįĻãĒãŗããĨãããŖãŧã¸ã¨äēæĨĩåããį¤žäŧã§ããããããã¨ããčč ãŽåŠč¨ã¯äŊã¨ãåˇĨå¤ĢããĻåžč ã§įãããããããĢãããã¨ã§ãããããã¯æ˛ãŋããčšãŽä¸įĒéĢãឿŋãĢããįģããŽã¨åããã¨ã§ããčǰããåŖãĢãããŽã¯įžäģŖãŽįĢļäēæŋåã§ãããį§ãŽčŗčŖãĢæãæĩŽããļãŽã¯ããēããŽå¤§įž¤ãé įšãįŽæããĻäēããããĢéãä¸ãå§ŋã§ãããã¸čžŋãįããĻãäģãŽããēãããĄããæ°åé ããĻæģãŦã ãã§ãã
ãããããĒãã¯į´äēå°åãã´ãįŧå´å ´ãææ¯åģæŖįŠææŖå ´ããšãĸãã°å°å¸¯ããšãŠã čĄãĒãŠããžããžãæåŽŗãĢãĒãä¸įãŽåąéēããã§ããã ãéĸããå ´æãĢčēĢãįŊŽããã¨ã¯ã§ããžãããį§ããĄãŽæäģŖãĢæãéãĒãåąæŠã¯ããããé˛åžĄãé ããæŠããæãĄį ´ãã§ããããæčŗããŠãã ãåæŖããĻããåŖãĢå˛ãžããåąæˇãĢéããŠãã ãããŖãĻããå°ä¸åޤãĢéŖæãŽįŧļ芰ããŠãã ãããŖãĻããįŊéŖã¨ããæŊŽæĩã¯ãããããĒããéŖ˛ãŋčžŧãã§ããžãã§ããããã˛ãŧããéĩãæåēéįˇãéã§įĸēäŋã§ããåŽå ¨ã¯ä¸æįãĒããŽãčŠæŦēįã§ä¸åŽãĒããŽã§ãããããžããããããĻį§ããĄãé˛įŠēåŖãŽåŋįæ§é ãæ¨ãĻãĻįč§Ŗãããã¨ãĢãĒããŽã¯ãåŽå ¨åŽåŋãå¯ä¸ããã¨ããã°ãããŽæēã¯ä¸ãããã¨ãéæžãããã¨ã§ãããčĒåˇąãŽãããĢå¤ããŽããŽãåĨĒããŽã§ã¯ãĒãæĩåįãĒäēēééĸäŋãŽä¸åŋãĢãããã¨ã ã¨ãããã¨ã§ããåŽå ¨åŽåŋã¯įŦįĢããã§ã¯ãĒãį¸äēäžåããįãžãããŽã§ããįãæŽããŽã¯čĻåĄãĢéãããããã¨ããč ã§ã¯ãĒããä¸ããåŠãããŗããĨãããŖãŧãĢč˛ĸįŽã§ããč ããĄã§ããåŊŧããæ°ããææãŽį¤ãåŊĸäŊããŽã§ãã
į§ããĄãčĨ˛ãåąæŠã¯10åš´ã20åš´ã¨ããæéãŽä¸ãĢéįĩãã¤ã¤ãããžããããŽä¸ã¤ä¸ã¤ãäģãŽåąæŠãåŧãčĩˇãããŽãĢä¸åŊšč˛ˇãŖãĻããã¨åæãĢãä¸ã¤ä¸ã¤ãæŦæ¸ã§čŋ°ãšãå ąéãŽæēããįããĻããžããæĨããšãããŽãŽå ãã¯ãæŋæ˛ģåŽļããããåŖåŽãĢäē翍ŠãįĄčĻããäēēã ãŽæ´ģåãŽįŖčĻč¨é˛ã¨ãŗãŗãããŧãĢãåŧˇåãããã¨ããã¨ããĢčĻããã¨ãã§ããžããåããã¨ããĸã¸ãĸã§ãŽSARSåąæŠãŽã¨ããĢãčĩˇãããĸãĄãĒãĢã§ãã¤ãŗããĢã¨ãŗãļã夊įļįãæĩčĄããå ´åãŽįˇæĨæå¯žåŋįã¨ããĻčĄããããããããžããããããĻæ´å˛įãĢããįĩæ¸į ´įļģã¨æŋæ˛ģįããĄãˇãēã ãŽéĸéŖæ§ã¯ååãĢįĢč¨ŧãããĻããžãããã§ãĢåš˛ã°ã¤ã¨įæ įŗģãŽčåģãéŖæ°ãįãŋå§ããĻããžãããįžå¨ãŽåąå°įãĒįŊåŽŗãåäŊããĻå°åįãããã¯å°įčĻæ¨ĄãŽį°åĸį ´åŖã¸ã¨č¨ãä¸ããŖãã¨ãããŠãŽãããĒæŋæ˛ģįä¸åŽåŽãįããããæŗåããĻãã ããããã§ãĢįŗæ˛šããããŖãĻååŊã¯æĻäēįļæ ãĢãããžãããã¨ããĢãŽãŧã ãã§ãĒãéŖįŗ§ãæ°´ãŽä¸čļŗãããããįĩæãæŗåããĻãã ããã
åčŋ°ããé°ã æģ ã ãŽãˇããĒãĒã¯ãčŠŗį´°ã¯ã¨ãããčĢčĒŋã¨ããĻã¯čĻæ ŖããããŽãĢæãããããããžããããčããĻãŋãĻãģãããŽã¯ããããåãĒããįĩãããã§ã¯ãĒããå§ãžãããĒãŽããããããį°ãĒãčĒåˇąæčãĢåēãĨãæ°ããæäģŖã¸ã¨į§ããĄãé§ãįĢãĻããåēįŖãŽåąæŠãããããĒãã¨ãããã¨ã§ããããã¯åēįŖãčĩˇãããŽãããŖã¨åž ãŖãĻããã°ããã¨ãããã¨ã§ã¯ãããžãããåąæŠãŽå°æĨã¯éŋããããĒããĢããããããããããåéŋãããããŽäŊä¸äģŖãĢããããæ´ģååŽļããĄãŽä¸čĻįĄé§ã¨ãæããåĒåããæĨĩããĻéčĻãĒãŽã§ããããããĒããããŽãããĒäēēã§ãįĩļæãĢįĢãĄåããããŠããããããĒã大ããĒåéĄãĢåãįĩãã§ãããŽãĒããããĒããŽäģäēã¯æąēããĻįĄé§ã§ã¯ãĒããã¨ãåŋãĢįããĻãããĻãã ãããåįå¯čŊã¨ããĢãŽãŧãåģæ°´ãŽãĒãĩã¤ã¯ãĢãå°åéč˛¨ãæšŋå°å¸¯ãŽäŋčˇãį¤žäŧãŽããããå´éĸãŽæšéŠãĒãŠããŠããĒåĒåãããŖãĻããĻãį ´åąãåéŋã§ããĒããŽã¯äēåŽã§ãããããããåĒåã¯įžäŊåļãå´ŠåŖããåžãã¤ãžã䏿¯č ãæåžãŽæčĄį寞įãäŊŋãæãããĻåēãæãŖãåžãĢčĩˇãããããå°įåįãŽãããŽį¨ŽãčããĻãããŽã§ãã
æįļå¯čŊã§čĒŋåããįæ´ģãéããŽãĢåŋ čĻãĒæčĄįč§Ŗæąēįã¯æĸãĢå ¨ãĻåå¨ããĻããĻãåŽéãã¤ã§ãåå¨ããĻãããŽã§ããåŋ čĻãĒãŽã¯æčãŽčģĸæã§ãããåäēēã¨ããĻãįįŠį¨Žã¨ããĻãŽį§ããĄčĒčēĢãŽåčĒčã§ããŖãĻããããéåģæ°ååš´ãŽéãĢæĄå¤§ããåæã¨æˇąãžãä¸åš¸ãéčģĸããããŽã§ãããããã¯éčĒŦįãĢãįĩæã¨ããĻããä¸ããããĒããŽã§ãã
į§ãč¨ãæčãŽčģĸæã¨ã¯ããããĒãæčĄįįēæãåæã¨ããããŽã§ããĒããã°ããã¯ããã¸ãŧæ°´æēãŽåžéãä¸ģåŧĩããããŽã§ããããžããããããããããã˛ã¨ããŗčĩˇãããĒããåŽã¯ããå§ãžãŖãĻãããŽã§ããããã¯ããã¸ãŧãŽå¤§ããĒåŊąéŋãåŊįļãŽãããĢé˛ãã§ããã§ããããå čĻãŽæãŽããäēēã ãäģããŽãããĒįŠčŗĒįãģį¤žäŧįãã¯ããã¸ãŧãéæããĻãããŽã¯ãæ§æ äžįļã¨ããįŽĄįã쿝é ãŽããæšããžããžãįĄįãĒããŽãĢãĒãŖãĻãããã¨ã¸ãŽå¯žåŋãĒãŽã§ããåŊŧããŽįēæãåēãæĄį¨ãããĒããŽã¯ãåŋ čĻãĒæčãŽå¤åãåãĢãžã įžããĻããĒãã¨ãããã¨ã§ããããã¯åãĢįžå¨ãŽį§ããĄãŽããæšã¨įįžããĻããã ãã§ããį§ããĄã¯įĨããšããã¨ãæĸãĢå ¨ãĻįĨãŖãĻããĻããžã į§ããĄããããžã§æéˇããĻããĒãã¨ããã ããĒãŽã§ãã
į¤žäŧãæįļå¯čŊãĒãã¯ããã¸ãŧãæå§ããäģįĩãŋã¯å ¨ãĻãæŦæ¸ãŽæ ¸åŋã§ããååĨã°ãã°ããŽčĒåˇąã¨ããåãåĻæŗãŽä¸ãĢæãįĢãŖãĻããžããįĩæ¸åĻã§ã¯ãããŽåĻæŗã¯åŠåã¨ãŗãšãå¤é¨åã¨ããĻįžããžããããããčļããããéåŖã¨ãĒãŖãĻéģåŽŗãããŽã¯ãåžĒį°ããæĩããåēãĢãããããģãšã§ããį§åĻã§ã¯åãåĻæŗããäŊãå¯čŊã§įžåŽįã§ããããĢã¤ããĻãäģãŽæĻåŋĩãčĻããĒãããæ°ããĒįč§Ŗã¨æ°ããĒãã¯ããã¸ãŧãŽåãå ĨããéģãéåŖãäŊãåēããžããåģåĻã§ã¯ãæ§æ äžįļã¨ãããæãã¨åŊŧããŽå¯žæąēãã¨ããčãæšãŽæ å ã§ãŽį įŠļãĢéä¸ãããŽã§ãæ°ããčĒåˇąå įĢįžæŖãĢã¯äŊčŗĒįãĢ寞åŋã§ãããäģãŽæ˛ģįæŗã¯éį§åĻįã ã¨åéĄãããžããæŋæ˛ģãæŗåžãæč˛ãŽåéã§ãčĻãĻãããŽã¯ãä¸įãŽį§Šåēåãæ°å¤åãæ¨æēåãæ¯é æĄå¤§ãĢįšãããĒããããĒč§ŖæąēįãããŗãŗãããŧãĢãŽããŠãã¤ã ãĢããŖãĻåãæ¨ãĻãããæ§åã§ãã
åæãŽäŊåļãæ°ããĒéĢãŋãĢéãããã¨ããĻããã¨ããäēåŽãå°įå ¨äŊãįåŊãŽééåã¨éĸäŋæ§ãŽåååãĢéĨãŖãĻããã¨ããäēåŽãä¸įã¨ãããĢããå ¨ãĻãŽããŽãæ°å¤åããååãäģããįŽĄįãããã¨ãããã¤ãĻãĒããģãŠæĨĩį̝ãĢãĒãã¤ã¤ããã¨ããäēåŽãããããã¨ããŖãĻãããŖã¨įžããä¸įã¸ãŽåąæãé ãŽããĻããããã§ã¯ãããžããããããã垏ãĢåããŖãĻæãĄå¯ããæŗĸãŽãããĢããåæãŽæäģŖãã¯å´ŠãčŊãĄã寸åãĢįŠēæ´åããĒããããæå¤§éãŽéĢããžã§įĢãĄä¸ãããžããå¤Ēå¤ãŽæãĢéåŊãĨããããĻããããŽå´ŠåŖããäģį§ããĄãŽįŽåãĢčŋĢãŖãĻãããŽã§ããããŽåžãĢį§ããĄãį¯ããã¨ãŽã§ããä¸įãåŖéčĻãããŽã¯ãããããããĒãĢãŋãããŖããīŧéä¸ģæĩãŽäģŖæŋææŗīŧã§ãããäģããŽåšæã¯ãģã¨ããŠįžããĻããžããã
įžå¨ã¸ã¨æãéãĒãåąæŠã¯ãäŊååš´ãåããæĒæĨãĢæ¸ãčžŧãžããĻããããŽã§ããããã¯æˇąãéåģãĢå§ãžãŖãåæãŽåŋ įļįãĒįĩæĢã§ãããä¸åēĻå§ãžãŖããįŠãŋéããĻããäģãããžãããčĒåããĄãčĒįļããåãéĸãããåå¨ã¨čĻãĒãå§ããįŦéãããį§ããĄãŽéåŊã¯æąēãžãŖãĻãããŽã§ããå´ŠåŖãéčŋãĢčŋĢãŖãĻãããŽã¯įžå¨ããžããĢãæããã§ãããä¸įããžã 大ãããį§ããĄããžã å°æ°ã§ãä¸įãäģč ã¨ããĻæąããã¨ãŽåŊąéŋããéãããããŖãäŊä¸į´ãäŊååš´ãåãĢããããäēčĻãããŽã¯ã¯ãããĢå°éŖã§ããããĢãããããããæ´å˛ãéããĻãéæãĒäēēã ã¯ä¸åãĒåå ãčĻæããĻããžãããããã¯į§ããĄãŽčĒåˇąčĻŗã¨ä¸įčĻŗãé§ãįĢãĻãå ãĢããåŋ įļįãĒįŽįå°ã§ãããã¯ããæãĢãįŊéŖãéããããã¤ã¤ããæåãŽå åãį§ããĄãŽčĒåˇąčĻŗãŽä¸ãĢæ¸ãčžŧãžããĻãããŽãåŊŧãã¯čĻæããããŽæ´å¯ãįĨčŠąã¨æ¯åŠãŽč¨čã§čĄ¨įžããžããã
åŊŧããŽæ¯åŠãŽããã¤ãã¯é常ãĢå°čąĄįã§ããããŠãŗãšãå¤ąãŖãįæ įŗģãčąĄåž´ããã¤ãã´ãŽįŊããį§ããĄãčĒãæããį ãčąĄåž´ããč ĢãįŠãŽįŊããæĻäēã¨ãæĻäēãŽåãããããŗãŽå¨ŧåŠĻã¯ãæ§ãŽåååã ãã§ãĒããįĨčãĒããŽå ¨čŦãéãŽãããĢåŖ˛ããã¨ãčąĄåž´ããĻããžããįžå¨ãĸãĄãĒãĢãŽåįä¸ģįžŠããĒãšãæã§æĩčĄããĻããįĩæĢä¸įãŽäēč¨ã¯ãæŦįŠãŽæ°äģããåēãĢããĻããžãããéãŖãĻãããŽã¯æããå¤é¨ããããããããã¨čãããã¨ã§ããåŊŧããæŗåãããŽã¯ãã¤ã¨ãšã夊ããéããĻããĻãįãŽäŋĄč ããĄã¯æåãŽä¸ãį§ããĄãį ´åŖããä¸įãããŽčąåēãĢå°ãããã¨ããããŽã§ããããã¯æčĄãĻãŧãããĸãäŋĄåĨããäēēã ã¨å ¨ãåãæčåŊĸæ ã§ãããã įĨãŽæŖäŊãéãã ãã§ãã
æãéãĒãåąæŠã¨ããåãæčãã大čĄį¤žäŧãĢčåģļããææã¨ããĻįĄæčãŽããĄãĢįžããžããčĒŋåãŽč¯ãæã¯æ°äģããĒããģãŠåžŽããĒããŽã§ããããŠããĒãĢč¯ãæã§ãäēēįããã¸ããšãŽæĩŽãæ˛ãŋãĢčåģļããå¨å˛ãŽä¸åŽãåããããã¨ã¯ã§ããžãããããã¯ãį§åĻãĢåãčžŧãžãããã¯ããã¸ãŧãŽč¨įģããæ¨é˛ããä¸åŽã¨å ¨ãåãããŽã§ããæåå ¨äŊãĢæãŋčžŧãã ä¸åŽãį ŊãįĢãĻããŽã¯ãį§ããĄãŽįšåž´ã§ãããŗãŗãããŧãĢã¸ãŽåŧˇčŋĢčĻŗåŋĩã§ãã
ããããŖãĻããããžã§äŊååš´ãĢããããŖãĻäēēã ãäēč¨ããĻããä¸įãŽįĩããã¯ãããããå°æĨããžãīŧ įĩæĢãŽæĨãããŗããŗå éããããã¨ã§ããŽäŋĄææ§ãæãĒããã¯ããžãããããŋã¤ã ãēãšã¯ã¨ãĸã§ããŠãĢãŧããæ˛ããå¤äēēããĄãŽčåžãĢããåēæŦįãĒåŋãŽã¨ããĢãŽãŧã¯ãæŦįŠãŽæēããæš§ãåēãããŽã§ããåŊŧããé ŧãŖãĻãããŽã¯æŦįŠãŽæ´å¯ã§ããææã¨ãã大åģēé įŠã¯ããããæįĩįãĢã¯å´ŠåŖãããã¨ãæąēåŽãĨããäŋŽåžŠä¸čŊãĒæ§é įæŦ éĨãæąããĻãããŽã§ããããŽãžãžčĄãã°ãį§ããĄã¯čĒįļã¨ãäēēéãŽæŦæ§ã¨ãčĄįĒããéåŊãĒãŽã§ãã
ããĢãã˛ããŗããŠã°ããã¯īŧä¸įãŽįĩãããĢãããæĻãīŧã¨ããŖãįĨ芹ãŽåĩå§č ãĢãžã§éĄããããŽéˇãããĒãšãæãŽäŧįĩąãä¸č˛ĢããĻéå°čŠäžĄããĻãããŽã¯ãåæããŠããžã§é˛ãããį§ããĄãå°éãããįå¤ããããĢæˇąãããããã¤ãææãŽå¤§åģēé įŠããŗãŗãããŧãĢãŽæčĄã§čŖäŋŽãčŖåŧˇããčŊåããŠããžã§ãããã¨ãããã¨ã§ãããããĻããããį§ãĢããžã ããŽæãæĨãĻããĒããŽã§ããããããį§ããĄã¯ãéåģãŽãã¯ããã¸ãŧããããããåŊąéŋãæĨæĄå¤§ãããŽãįŽĄįãįļãããã¨ãĢãĒãã§ãããããããããįæ įŗģãæŋæ˛ģãčäŊããå¤ąãããæŠčŊãčŖããã¨ããæģãĢįŠįããŽåĒåã¯ããããããæåããã§ãããããããããį¤žäŧãčĒįļãæåãéãŽčŗæŦãããžã æŗåãã¤ããĒããããĒæ°ããĒé åãįēčĻããæ°¸įļįãĒæéˇãŽåååã¨ãĒããŽã§ãããã
ããããããã°ãããŽéã¯ãã§ããã¨ãčŋĢãæĨãåąæŠãŽéįĩãįžåš´å ãžã§éŖãæĸããæšæŗãčĻã¤ããã¨ããĻããį§ãŽã芹ããããã¨ãééãã¨ãããã¨ãĢã¯ãĒããžããã
æŗ¨įŽããšããã¨ãĢãããããŽä¸įįĩæĢįĨ芹ãĢã¯å ąéįšãããŖãĻãįĩãããŽã¯ä¸įããŽããŽã§ã¯ãĒããæã ãįĨãŖãĻããä¸įãįĩãããŽã ã¨ãããã¨ã§ããįĩæĢæĻäēãŽãããĢãããŽåžãŽä¸įã¯į´æãįĨ芹ã¨ããĻéåįįĄæčãĢæåŊąãããžããåŋãŽåĨĨåēã§ãį§ããĄã¯įããŖã¨č¯ãä¸įãå¯čŊã ã¨åããŖãĻããžããįĩåąãŽã¨ãããããŽįč§ŖãããæŦæ¸ãŽåé ã§čŋ°ãšãããããŧããæĒæĨã īŧãã¨ããįĨ芹ãįãŋåēãããŽã§ããŖãĻãããã¯ããã¸ãŧãŽč¨įģãã¨ããã¤ããĒããŽãŧãŽããã§ã¯ãããžãããããã¯ããã¸ãŧãŽč¨įģãã¨ããã¤ããĒããŽãŧã¯ãį´æįãĢæãåãŖãããŽæĒæĨããå´ŠåŖãĢããŖãĻã§ã¯ãĒããäģãžã§ã¨åãæšåãĢįĒãé˛ãã§ããã°åžãããã¨ä¸ģåŧĩããĻæ¨ĒåããããŽã§ãã
åãįč§Ŗã¯å¤ãããäŧãã夊åŊãŽįĨ芹ãĢã襨ããĻããĻãäēå čĢã¨ããäŊåļãŽä¸ã§įæŗåããæŊ蹥åãããĻãå°ä¸ããåãéĸãããé åãĢčŋŊãããããĻã¯ããžãããé åŠįãĒãŦããĢã§ã¯į§ããĄãŽįĨãŖãĻããäēēįãåŋ įļįãĢįĩãããã¨ãį¤ēåããĻããžãã夊åŊãĢå ĨããããŽæįļãã§ããããĩã¤ãã¯åžæĨãŽčĒåˇąãŽčļ čļãäŧ´ããžããããã¯å¤ãããæšãææžããã¨ã§ãããããĒãšãæåŧãĢč¨ãã°ãããĒãšããŽããĄãĢįãžãå¤ãããã¨ã§ããåããããĢãæãéãĒãåąæŠãŽåžãĢäēēéĄãå°éã§ããčŧãããå°äŊã¯ãį§ããĄãčĒįļã¨ã¯åĨã§čĒįļãŽæŗåããå é¤ãããã¨ããéåŖįčĒåˇąåŽįžŠãå´ŠããåžãĢããč¨Ēããžããã
čŋäģŖãéããĻįš°ãčŋãããĻãããĻãŧãããĸã¨ãããã¸ã§ãŗã¯åãĒããã¯ããã¸ãŧä¸ģįžŠįãĒããããŦãŗãäģĨä¸ãŽããŽã§ãããäģæĨį§ããĄãäŊãä¸ããããŽãéĨããĢčļ ããįžããä¸įãå¯čŊã ã¨ããæŽéįãĒįĸēäŋĄãĢãčŗãåžããĻãã ãããããããããĻãŧãããĸãã¨ããč¨čãŽæåéããŽæåŗã¯ãåå¨ããĒãå ´æããĒãŽã§ãã[1]ãį§ããĄããããžã§å°ãããããĒį¨ŽéĄãŽåĒåã§ã¯ãããŽãããĒä¸įãåŽįžãããã¨ã¯ã§ããžããããĻãŧãããĸã¯ãããåĒããį§åĻãããį˛žå¯ãĒæčĄãå å¤ãŽįžåŽãããį´°ãããŗãŗãããŧãĢãããã¨ãĢããŖãĻéæãããããŽã§ã¯ãããžãããåč¯ã§ãããã¨åĒåããĻããčĒįļãäēēéãŽæŦæ§ã䏿ããŗãŗãããŧãĢããĻãåŽįžããžãããå ¨ãéã§ããį§ããĄãäŊãåēãããå°įãã¯ãčĒįļããĸãæąããããŗãŗãããŧãĢãããã¨ããäŧãĻããå§ãžãŖããŽã§ããããŽäŧãĻã¨ããããĢäģéããčĒåˇąæĻåŋĩãčļ čļãããã¨ãĢããŖãĻãããįžå¨į§ããĄãįŊŽãããĻããįļæŗããããĢåŧˇåããäģĨå¤ãŽäŊããįãŋåēããã¨ã¯æããžããã
ååš´įåŊãĢããįĩæĢäēč¨ã¨åããããĢããæ°´įļåē§ãŽæäģŖããŽå°æĨãåããããĨãŧã¨ã¤ã¸ãŽåŽŖč¨ããžããæŠãįããĻããĒããã¨ãč¨ŧæãããĻããžããããããããããŽãã¸ã§ãŗãåã ã¨ãããã¨ãĢã¯ãĒããžããã60åš´äģŖãŽããããŧããĄãĢįãããããĒãåããŖãĻãããŽã¯ããã¨10åš´ãããã°ãæĻäēããéãæŗåžãåĻæ ĄãĒãŠãå ¨ãĻãæäģŖé ããĢãĒããã¨ã§ãããåŊŧããčĻãĻãããŽã¯æŦåŊãŽæĒæĨãæŦåŊãŽåŋ įļã§ãããã¯åŊŧããŽå¤ããæ¯į§åģãĢãĒãŖãã¨ããäēåŽãĢããŖãĻåĻåŽãããããŽã§ã¯ãããžãããäģĨåãį§ãŽå ãčģä¸ĄįŽĄįåąãŽåãĢä¸Ļãã§ããã¨ããéŖãĢįĢãŖãĻããå ããããŧãããč¨ããžããããäŋēããĄããããĒãã¨ã¨ã¯į¸ãåãŖãã¯ãã ãŖãããã60åš´äģŖãĢããčĄåããæ¸éĄããčēĢåč¨ŧææ¸ãĒããĻãŽã¯ãįĩããŖãĻãã¯ãã ãŖãããããããããŧããĄãŽįŽãĢæããã ãŖããŽã¯ãããããåļåēĻã¯å ¨ãĻæäģŖé ãã§ãããæĄå¤§ããæčãæĨéãĢå°įãčĻãŖãĻããä¸ã§čĄ°éããĻãããã¨ã§ããããã¨æ°åš´ã§ããããåŽįžããã¯ãã§ããã
ããããŧããĄã¯ééãŖãĻããžããã§ãããåŽéãæ§ææãŽįĩãããä¸ģčĻŗįãĢäŊé¨ããč ããĄãããĻããããĒãã¯ãšãããŽčąčŊã¨ããĻčĒåčĒčēĢãŽįæļ¯ãŽããĄãĢåŊĸãįžããžãããåšžäēēãã¯äģæĨãį¤žäŧãŽįéã§ããģã¨ããŠčǰãŽįŽãĢãč§ĻãããĢįããĻããĻããéãæŗåžãæĻäēãåŊŧããŽäŊé¨ãĢã¯åĢãžããĻããžãããåŊŧãã¯ä¸åŊãŽäŧčĒŦãĢįģå ´ããéæãŽäģäēēãŽãããĒããŽã§ãæŽéãŽį¤žäŧããéĸããĻäēēééĸããåąąåĨĨã¸ã¨æļããĻãããéå¸¸ãŽæåã§įŽé ããããäēēãŽįŽãĢã¯čĻãããäēēéãŽåéĄãĢå Ĩãčžŧãã§ãããã¨ããģã¨ããŠãããžãããããäģĨå¤ãŽãæ¯į§åģãåŧčˇåŖĢãĢãĒããããĢčĒåãŽãã¸ã§ãŗããčēĢãåŧããäēēããĄãĢã¨ãŖãĻããããģãŠæįĸēã§čĒŦåžåãŽããããŽãĢčĻããæĒæĨã¯ãæĒæĨãŽãžãžã§ãããåŊŧããčĻããŽã¯įåŽã§ããããããŽãã¸ã§ãŗãŽæéįč§ŖéããããĻããã ããĒãŽã§ãã
ãããåŋ įļįãǿǿĨã§ãããã¨ã¯įĸēãã§ãããéčĒŦįãĒč¨ãæšãããã°ãįžãŽįčˇĄãŽæåžãŽã˛ã¨ããããäŊŋãæããããŽæĨãžã§įĄæéãĢå éãããåããį§ããĄãĢã¯ããã¨ãããã¨ã§ããããžãã
å¤ããŽäēēã ãĢã¨ãŖãĻãåąæŠãŽéįĩã¯ããæĸãĢčĩˇããŖãĻããĻãããããŧãéæãŽäģäēēãŽãããĢããŗãŗãããŧãĢããæį¸ããåãéĸãããčĒåˇąãŽæĻåŋĩãææžããåæãŽãã¯ããã¸ãŧããéĸããĻåããå ãĢã¯ãč˛¨åšŖãæč˛ãæčĄãåģįãč¨čĒãŽæ°ããĒåļåēĻãäŊįŗģããããžããæ§ã ãĒæšæŗã§ãåŊŧãã¯ãæŠæĸ°ããŽįĩįšããčēĢãåŧããžããåąæŠãæãéãĒãã¨ãæŽæŽĩéããŽįæ´ģã¯ãã¯ãæåŗããĒããĒããĒããåįã¸ãŽéãéãŽå¤åŽšãĢåããéãéãããžããããããæäģŖãŽįĨį§ä¸ģįžŠč ããĄã¯ã夊åŊã¯äēēįã¨æéãŽæãĻãĢããé ãåĨãŽé åã§ã¯ãĒãããããæŽæŽĩãŽåå¨ãĢæãŋæ¸ĄãŖãĻããĻããã¤ã§ãæãŽåąãã¨ãããĢããã¨čĒčããĻããžãããã¤ã¨ãšã¯ããč¨ãŖãĻããžãããįļãŽįåŊã¯į§ããĄãŽä¸ãĢãããį§ããĄãŽéãĢããããããããããˇãĨãŧãģããŠãã¯ãšããããĒãšããŽåč¨ããĢčžŧããæˇąé ãĒæåŗã§ããåŽĸčĻŗįãĒæéãŽä¸ãŽåä¸ãŽæįĸēãĒåēæĨäēã§ã¯ãĒããæéįãĢéĸããæŖįēįã§ãããĒããåŋ įļįãĒãį§ããĄãŽããĒãšãæčã¸ãŽįŽčĻããŽįˇäŊãĒãŽã§ã[2]ãį§ããĄãŽæäģŖãįšåĨãĒãŽã¯ãéåŖãŦããĢã§ãŽåæãŽãããģãšãŽåŽæããããŽãããĒåäēēįãĒåąæŠãŽéįĩã¨ããããĢįļãæ°ããĒčĒåˇąæčã¸ãŽįŽčĻãããå¤ããŽäēēã ãĢ䏿ãĢåŧãčĩˇãããĻãããã¨ã§ãã
éˇããå¤ąãããĻããéģéæäģŖãåãæģãã¨ããį´æã¯ãæ°ãåããĒããģãŠãŽįĨ芹ãĢãã ãžããĻããžããåŋãŽį´įˇãĢč§ĻãããŽã¯ãå¤Ēå¤ãŽæããįŠēæŗåŽļãįæŗä¸ģįžŠč ãéŧčããĻããããŽã§ããã¨ãããĢãããããĢãäēēéãŽč¸ããæ°¸é ãĢæš§ãåēããæļããã¨ãŽã§ããĒã叿ãčĒŦæããĻããžãããžãããããį ŊãåĨå ¨ãĒ䏿ēã¯ãįžäģŖįãĒä¸åŽãŽčŖčŋãã§ãį§ããĄãĢã§ãããŽã¯éĢã ããŽį¨åēĻãĒãŽã ã¨ã¯äŋĄããããžãããããŽæ¤ããããŽéããĒæãã¯ãåŋĢéŠããč´ æ˛ĸãĢããŖãĻ䏿įãĢåããããã¨ãã§ããįåä¸åŽãĢããŖãĻ䏿įãĢæãčžŧããã¨ãã§ãã常ãĢčĨč ãĢæãåŧˇãįžããį§ããĄå ¨åĄãŽä¸ãĢæŊãã§ããĻãååčģãŽãããĒįæŗä¸ģįžŠã¸ã¨é§ãįĢãĻãããæēåã¯å¸¸ãĢã§ããĻããžããããã°ãã°ãããįãŋåēããĻããįļæŗããŽããŽãæ°¸įļããããããĢåŠį¨ããããŽã§ããčĻĒæãĒãčĒč ãŽįãããį§ãŽįŽįã¯ãããĒããŽæ¤ããäģŖåŧããäēēįã¯ããŖã¨į´ æ´ãããããŽã ã¨ããį´æįãĒįč§ŖãåįĸēčĒãããã¨ãĒãŽã§ããæåžãĢãæ´å¯åãŽããæŧĢįģäŊåŽļãããĒãã¯ãģããĄãŧãĒãŧãĢãããéåģã¨æĒæĨãŽãéģéæäģŖããĢã¤ããĻãŽåæ įãĒæåãį´šäģããžãããã
į§ããĄãæ¸åŊãĢéãŽåĒåãããĻãããĢãããããããã¤ããĢį§ããĄãŽååĢããäēããåˇã¤ãããĢįããæšæŗãčĻã¤ãããĒãŠã¨ãããĒããį§ã¯äŋĄããããã ãããīŧ
åŊŧããįãŠããģãŠčŖįĻãĢãĒãããããĒããį§ã¯äŋĄããããã ãããīŧ
į§ãŽæžåĢå¨ã¨ããŽåäēēããĄããįããĻãããã¨ããŠããģãŠæŋããæããããããŽæãåšéŖįãĒæ°åãĒãŠã§ã¯ãĒããå¯ãĻãčĻããĻãäēēįãŽä¸įŦä¸įŦãč˛Ģããå°Ŋãããã¨ãŽãĒãåã ã¨ãããã¨ããããĒããį§ã¯ä¸įŦã§ãįč§Ŗã§ããã ãããīŧ
ããĒããį§ã¯äŋĄããããã ãããīŧ ãããäŋĄãããĢčããããã ãããīŧ[3]
ããŽįĢ ã§čĒŦæãããŽã¯ãæĒæĨãŽãã¯ããã¸ãŧãããŽį¤žäŧåŊĸæ ã¨įŠčŗĒįįŖãŽããŠãã¤ã ãĢã¤ããĻã§ããããŽæĒæĨã¨ã¯įåŊãæããæĒæĨã§ãããããŽæã¨ã¯įããĻãããã¨ã¸ãŽæã¨ãįãã¨ãįããããŽã¸ãŽæãåĢãããŽã§ãããããã¯å ¨ãĻãčĒåˇąã¨ä¸įãĢ寞ããåĨãŽįč§Ŗããįãžãããããå ˇäŊåããžããįžå¨ãŽį¤žäŧåŊĸæ ããã¯ããã¸ãŧãåæããįãžããåæãåŧˇåãããŽã¨åããããĢã21ä¸į´ãŽãã¯ããã¸ãŧãåæãéčģĸããåå ã§ããįĩæã§ããããã¨ãčĻãĻãããžãããããã¯åŽåŽãĢ寞ããå ¨ãį°ãĒãįč§Ŗã§ããŖãĻãåŋįåĻããåŽåŽčĢãĢčŗããžã§ããããããŦããĢã§æãããĢãĒãŖãĻããžãããããžį§ããäŧããããã¨ãããŽã¯ãæãææãĒį¤žäŧįãģįŠčŗĒįãã¯ããã¸ãŧãŽį¨ŽããããžčŊãåēããĻãååä¸ãŽæäģŖãã¸ã¨æéˇããčąãå˛ãããããŖãŗãšãåžãĻæēéãŽčąãå˛ããããããŠãŽãããĒããŽãĢãĒããã¨ãããã¸ã§ãŗã§ããåąæŠãæŋåãããĢã¤ããį§ããĄã¯æ°ããĒé¸æã¨æ°ããĒå¯čŊæ§ãĢį´éĸãããã¨ãĢãĒããžãããããĻæãéãããã§ããã鏿ãŽåŊąéŋã¨åãŽå ¨ãĻããčĒčãããã§ã¯ãããžãããã
åīŧãéēäŧåã§æēãĄãä¸į
įŽæŦĄ
æŦĄīŧãååã¨ããé貨
æŗ¨īŧ
[1] čĒæēã¯ãŽãĒãˇãŖčĒã§ãč¯ãããæåŗããeu-ã§ã¯ãĒããããĒãããæåŗããou-ã§ããã
[2] ããˇãĨãŧãģããŠãã¯ãš[Fox, Matthew,]ãThe Coming of the Cosmic ChristīŧåŽåŽįããĒãšããŽå°æĨīŧã, HarperSanFrancisco, 1988åš´.
[3] ãããĒãã¯ãģããĄãŧãĒãŧ[Farley, Patrick,] ãChrysalis Colossusīŧã¯ãĒãĩãĒãšãŽåˇ¨åīŧã, www.e-sheep.com/chrysalis
[荺č¨ģ1]ãįŠäēãããŠããŠãĢãĒããīŧThings Fall Apartīŧã¯ãããĸãģãĸãã§ããĢããå°čĒŦãå´ŠãããįĩããŽåéĄã
[荺č¨ģ2]ãæ¯ãããæ¨ã
īŧãĸãĄãĒãĢãŽæŖŽæãčĨ˛ãįĢį
īŧThe Dying of the Trees: The Pandemic in America's ForestsīŧãããŖãŧãĢãēãģEãģãĒããĢ [Charles E. Little]īŧ1995åš´īŧãããĨãŧã¤ãŗã°ãŠãŗããããĢãĒããŠãĢããĸãžã§ãå
¨įąŗåå°ã§å¤ąãããæ¨šæ¨ãčĒŋæģããį°åĸåĻč
ããé
¸æ§é¨ããĒãžãŗãį´Ģå¤įˇãæŖŽæįäŧãĒãŠãäēēéãäŊãåēããåå ã¨ãį§åĻč
ãæŋåēã叿°ãŽååŋã¨įĄéĸåŋãæãã
ãæ˛¸įšīŧæŋæ˛ģåŽļã大æįŗæ˛šäŧį¤žãįŗįäŧį¤žãã¸ãŖãŧããĒãšããæ´ģååŽļã¯ãããĢããĻæ°ååąæŠãį
ŊãŖãĻãããâãããĻįŊåŽŗãåéŋãããããĢã§ãããã¨īŧBoiling Point: How Politicians, Big Oil and Coal, Journalists, and Activists Have Fueled a Climate Crisis -- And What We Can Do to Avert Disasterīŧã ããšãģã˛ãĢããšããŗ [Ross Gelbspan]īŧ2004åš´īŧãå°į渊æåãŽåéĄããããã¨ãčĒãã¤ã¤ãäēŦéŊč°åŽæ¸ãĢåžããã¨ãæåĻããåįŗįæã¸ãŽäžåãåŧˇããã¨ããĢãŽãŧæŋįãã¨ããĸãĄãĒãĢæŋåēã¨įŖæĨįãŽįģįãæãã
ãŠãĄããæĨæŦæĒ荺ã
åæãĒãŗã¯īŧhttps://ascentofhumanity.com/text/chapter-7/
