Introduction

Climate change has created novel animal communities in transitional environments, particularly in the Arctic and Subarctic where range expansion may occur as temperatures warm and cool. The archaeological record offers an opportunity to examine the effects of changing climate on local ecology, biogeography, and human-animal interactions at periods of changing climate. For example,

Alaska’s Aleutian Islands are described as a temperate maritime environment, where the UnangaxΜ‚ (Aleut)Β and their ancestors have lived for more than 9,000 years. However, the archaeological record of the eastern Aleutian Islands has revealed that the Neoglacial climatic phase - approximately 4700β€‰βˆ’β€‰2500 rcyr BP - was significantly colder, and that the local environment likely supported sea ice and ice-dependent mammals1,2. In particular, animal bone remains from the Margaret Bay (UNL-048) and Amaknak Bridge (UNL-050) archaeological sites in Unalaska Bay (Fig.Β 1) provide zooarchaeological evidence that people harvested a suite of novel species during this period, including ringed seal (Phoca hispida), bearded seal (Erignathus barbatus), and possibly polar bear (Ursus maritimus), none of which reside in the eastern Aleutian Islands today. Archaeologists have used the Unalaska Bay archaeological record to suggest that Arctic mammals’ range expanded as far south as Unalaska Island during the Neoglacial phase, facilitated by expanding Bering Sea ice.

Previous analyses of the Margaret Bay and Amaknak Bridge fauna have assumed that the pagophilic mammals were hunted locally and therefore represent significant environmental change and hunting adaptation1,2,3,4. In particular, the putative archaeological polar bears have been the subject of multiple publications that apply them as a marker for bear range expansion and changing climate conditions1,5,6. This identification may have significant implications for our understanding of paleoenvironments, bear biogeography, and bear evolutionary history. For example, during the Last Glacial Maximum (26.5 to 19Β ka)7in regions where sea ice overlapped with habitat occupied by brown bears (e.g. southeast Alaska and Ireland), there was gene flow between the two species8,9,10. It is possible that habitat overlap and subsequent hybridization also occurred more recently during the Neoglacial period in the Aleutian Islands.

However, two problems complicate this story: first, polar bears and brown bears (U. arctos) are nearly impossible to distinguish based on postcranial skeletal remains because of extensive intraspecific variation and sexual dimorphism11,12. Previous reports have not described the morphology of the bear remains, nor the criteria used for identification2,13. Second, ancestral UnangaxΜ‚ traveled widely by boat and traded with other communities throughout coastal Alaska4,5. Rather than a local harvest, the Unalaska Bay bear remains may represent long-distance travel or trade. To use the Unalaska Bay bear bones as a marker for bear range expansion, changing climate conditions, and as a proxy for human adaptation, these problems must be addressed.

The Unalaska Bay archaeological record provides a unique opportunity to address questions about bears in a place where they have never been found. This small collection deserves further scrutiny for three reasons: (1) literature on distinguishing brown and polar bear is almost non-existent; (2) bear comparative specimens are very difficult to access; and (3) descendent UnangaxΜ‚ communities will incorporate the detailed analysis as part of their history. Here, we use zooarchaeological methods to assess whether the bears can be distinguished to species and to test whether these animals were harvested locally and represent a range expansion.

Previous research

Several archaeological sites have been excavated around Unalaska Bay on Amaknak Island (Fig.Β 1) and bear remains were recovered from two of these sites: Margaret Bay (UNL-048; 4700β€‰βˆ’β€‰4000 rcyr BP) and Amaknak Bridge (UNL-050; 3500β€‰βˆ’β€‰2500 rcyr BP). Ancestral UnangaxΜ‚ built villages of semi-subterranean houses and deposited midden material, or refuse, at these sites4,16. The radiocarbon chronology indicates these sites were occupied during the onset and into the height of the Neoglacial phase, which was widespread across Alaska and marked by glacial expansion and progressive cooling of several degrees C over this 2000-year period17.

Previous zooarchaeological analysis of the faunal material from the two sites revealed a variety of marine mammals, including both temperate species typical of modern Aleutian assemblages and novel, ice-obligate species. At Margaret Bay, Davis (2001) concluded that a small percentage of the identifiable material belonged to polar bear (0.2%) and brown bear (2%), while the majority of the elements were not identifiable to species. At Amaknak Bridge, Crockford et al. (2004) found a very small number of bear specimens (< 1%) and fragments of large terrestrial mammals, which they identified as likely polar bear. However, none of the skeletal elements were described and criteria for distinguishing polar from brown bear were not provided.

The presence of bears in the Unalaska Bay assemblages is surprising because there are no historical or paleontological records of brown or polar bears in Unalaska. Today, the closest brown bear populations can be found on the Alaska Peninsula and as far west as Unimak Island, which is ca. 60 miles east of Unalaska (Fig.Β 1), while polar bear populations are rarely found south of St. Lawrence Island today18. The farthest southern extent of polar bears in the historical record is a bear observed in 1875 on St. Paul Island in the Pribilof Islands5, which is ca. 500 miles north of Unalaska.

To our knowledge, there is no documented history of people on Unalaska Island hunting or utilizing bear products. However, the Aleut Dictionary provides terms for β€œwhite bear”, tanĝaaĝim quhmaa (W), tanĝaaĝim qumaa (E); β€œice bear”, kdam tanĝaaĝii (E), β€œnorthern bear”, chugumhada(n) tanĝaaĝii (W); β€œblack bear”, tanĝaaĝim qaxchikdaa (W), tanĝaaĝim qaxchikluu (E); and β€œbrown bear”, tanĝaaĝim chumnugaa(E)19(W indicates the Western dialect and E indicates the Eastern dialect), indicating that UnangaxΜ‚ were familiar with all three bear species. Bear stories and legends have been recorded in the Aleutians, and there is some ethnohistorical documentation expressing the significance of brown bears in ceremonial ways. Black (1998) describes UnangaxΜ‚ connections to brown bears as β€œsymbolically very important” even though their historical range was confined to the eastern region. This symbolism included brown bears as protectors2and powerful animals whose name could not be spoken2, with the hunt and the products of the hunt bestowing honor and protection to the hunter2. UnangaxΜ‚ were known to travel long distances, where they would have encountered brown bears on Unimak Island and the Alaska Peninsula, or perhaps as far as the Kodiak archipelago14.

Fig. 1
Fig. 1
Full size image

Map showing the location of the Margaret Bay (ca. 4700 rcyr BP) and Amaknak Bridge (ca. 2500 rcyr BP) archaeological sites. Bear symbols represent tentatively identified species at Margaret Bay and uncertain species identity at Amaknak Bridge. Map was produced using ArcGIS online (ESRI 2024)87.

Fig. 2
Fig. 2
Full size image

Polar bear mandible from Margaret Bay; top, occlusal view; bottom, medial view.

Fig. 3
Fig. 3
Full size image

Principal component analysis of a) proximal phalanges, and b) metacarpals. Orange triangles = Museum polar bears, green circles = Museum brown bears, open squares = hybrid individuals, black stars = Margaret Bay specimens.

Fig. 4
Fig. 4
Full size image

Bear skeleton showing locations of cut marks and a magnified picture (100X) of cut marks from the scapula. Mark locations are approximate. Blue shading indicates elements from Margaret Bay; orange shading indicates elements from Amaknak Bridge.

Adjacent to Unalaska, brown bears reside in high density on the western Alaska Peninsula and Unimak Island (Fig.Β 1), though subsistence studies in UnangaxΜ‚ communities within the brown bears’ range on the Alaska Peninsula and Unimak Island do not document bears currently being harvested for food3,4. The False Pass subsistence survey of 1987/88 recorded information from an elder that β€œbrown bears are no longer used for subsistence in the community, although they have been in the past”24. In another household, a woman who grew up in Belkoski described men there hunting brown bears for meat and hides when she was a child24. Across coastal Alaska and Siberia5,6, both polar and brown bears were traditionally used for meat in many communities, but people also sought hides for clothing and bedding, fat for dipping dried fish and other foods, bones and sinews for cordage and tools, intestines for garments, teeth and claws for decoration and tools, and other uses7,8,9,1. Bears are relatively rare in the archaeological record of the Gulf of Alaska and Bering Sea, where zooarchaeological assemblages are dominated by marine fish and marine mammals (e.g2,3,4,5.).

Methods

Sample collection

The Margaret Bay site (UNL-048) was excavated in 1996–1997 and fauna were collected using ¼” water screen16. The mammal specimens were identified by Davis (2001) at the University of Alaska Fairbanks, using comparative specimens at the Museum of the North. We examined 33 specimens previously identified as bears from a single midden context at Margaret Bay (TableΒ 1). The Amaknak Bridge site (UNL-050) was excavated in 2000 and 2003 and faunal remains were collected as bulk samples or by using ¼” water screen36. The mammal specimens were identified by Pacific Identifications13, using comparative specimens at the University of Victoria. For this study, we examined six specimens previously identified as bears from a single midden context at Amaknak Bridge (TableΒ 1, Supplementary Table S1). We sampled identifiable elements from these collections to tease out whether they could be identified as polar or brown bear. We acknowledge there are likely more bear specimens in the collections that were not pulled during the initial sampling due the fragmented nature of the collection, and this sampling strategy limits the analysis.

Each specimen was photographed and 3D scanned (Arctic Data Center: https://doi.org/10.18739/A2DR2PB2Z). Additionally, 3D models of Margaret Bay specimens were printed and used in a K-12 lesson plan entitled β€œMystery of the Margaret Bay bones.” To solicit local assistance in solving the mystery, as well as to inform local communities about the research conducted on these materials, the 3D models and the lesson are publicly available on Thingiverse with permission from the Ounalashka Corporation and the Museum of the Aleutians (Thingiverse number 5476596).

Taxonomic identification

Skeletal differences between brown and polar bears are limited and not widely published. The cranium and mandible are most distinctive: polar bears exhibit craniodental adaptations related to their hypercarnivorous diet, including significantly reduced molar size, larger canines, a slender body or horizontal ramus, and a lower, more slender cranium relative to brown bears37,38. Because of significant intraspecific variation in brown bears and sexual dimorphism in both species, most postcranial elements are difficult to distinguish and there are few published identification criteria, to our knowledge11. Polar bears have shorter, more curved claws than brown bears, perhaps for grasping prey39, though these are difficult to distinguish using archaeological specimens because the nail sheath (keratin) is typically absent. Sexual dimorphism in both species and the unknown sex of the elements add to this difficulty.

To determine whether we could differentiate between brown and polar bear elements, we took linear morphometric measurements on the archaeological and modern specimens following Tsoukala and Grandal-d’Anglade (2002)40. While published metric data exist for prehistoric bears in European and Asian contexts (e.g41,42), we limited our comparative sample to North America to control for geographic and temporal variability in bear size. We took comparative measurements from modern North American brown bears, polar bears, and hybrid bears at the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History and Sam Noble Oklahoma Museum of Natural History (Supplementary Table S2). These measurements were taken on bears of both sexes but were limited to fully-fused adult specimens to control for size and morphological differences across age classes. All measurements were taken in triplicate with a digital caliper by the same person and the average was used in principal components analysis (PCA) performed with the MorphoTools2v1.0.1.1 package43 in R (R v2.4.1). Because most of the archaeological specimens are fragmentary, the number of complete measurements that could be compared to museum references was limited. Therefore, we ran PCA analysis only on complete elements, including metacarpals and proximal phalanges (Supplementary Table S2). Measurements from metacarpals 2–3 and phalanges 2–4 were combined to increase the sample size and because these are difficult to differentiate.

Aging

To estimate the age categories of bears represented in this sample, we classified the skeletal elements using methods proposed by Weinstock (2009) for brown bears. Each bone specimen was aged using the extent of epiphyseal fusion, and the resolution is in years based on the museum specimens used to establish the aging protocol44(Supplementary Table S3a. and S3b.). The estimate of the minimum number of individual animals (MNI) is based on non-repeating landmarks of the most abundant skeletal element in the assemblages, taking into account ontogenetic differences45. This is a minimum measure, as there can be significant variation in age estimates44.

Loose teeth were aged using tooth root pulp cavity closure as described by Parker and Maxwell (1986)47(Supplementary Table S3a. and S3b.). We sliced each tooth root perpendicular to the axis of growth at its thickest point with a Dremel fitted with a diamond wheel and measured the tooth root cavity and cementum using digital calipers. While tooth pulp ratio age models have been estimated for other carnivores (e.g., wolves, wolverines, coyotes, martens, and jackals)48,49,50,51,52, they have not been developed for bears. Therefore, we classified root closure at less than 50% as β€œimmature” bears and greater than 50% as β€œmature” bears over four years of age. We also evaluated dental wear53,54to assign broad age categories following Guskov (2014)55and Rausch (1961)56. Here, these broad categories include unworn teeth (< 3 years), incisors begin to display wear (4–6 years of age), molars begin to wear and incisors worn evenly across surfaces (6–11 years).

Table 1 Archaeological specimens examined in this study. Additional details provided in supplementary table S1.
Table 2 Age of epiphyseal fusion based on Weinstock (2009). Shaded bars represent the earliest and latest ages of fusion for the individual skeletal elements and the elements listed are limited to those identified in the UNL-48 assemblage.

Based on bear management literature, we have designated broad categories for the aged bears that include both behavior and reproductive age. Specimens that appear under age 1 are classified as "young cub”; specimens aged 1-2 years and under are considered dependent on their mothers and are classified as β€œcubs”; specimens aged 3–4 are likely not of reproductive age but are independent of their mothers and are classified as β€œsubadult”; and specimens over the age of 5 are classified as mature or β€œadult”57,58 (TableΒ 2).

Bone modification

All specimens were examined for the presence of anthropogenic modifications (cut marks) and pathologies. All cut marks visible to the naked eye were examined by two analysts, and subsequently observed and photographed at 10-100X magnification with a Dino-Lite USB Digital Microscope and the DinoCapture 2.0 software. Cut marks were defined as clusters (2 or more) of straight, v-shaped, relatively deep marks without major color differentiation (e.g59). These criteria distinguish anthropogenic cut marks from shallow, U-shaped, and/or sinuous marks that are more likely caused by other environmental factors (e.g., root etching or trampling)60. Pathologies were documented and photographed61,62. Tooth wear was identified following Winer et al. (2016, 2017)53,54. Specimens were also analyzed for the presence or absence of other taphonomic modifications, including weathering, root etching, carnivore gnawing, and burning. For this analysis weathering stages were recorded following the system developed by Behrensmeyer (1978)63, where each stage demonstrates progressively greater damage from 0 (no weathering) to 5 (advanced exfoliation)Β (Table S1).

Results

Taxonomic identification

Our comparative morphological examination of the archaeological specimens suggested a mix of polar and brown bear. In the Margaret Bay assemblage, the mandible is identifiable as polar bear using morphological characteristics that distinguish it from brown bear, including the narrow molars and thin body35,36 (Fig.Β 2). Despite the difficulty of distinguishing bear post-cranial material and the small sample size, the PCA analysis of the phalanges and metapodials show some promise. It is difficult to distinguish phalanges from the fore and hind paws by number based on archaeological material; however, the metacarpals were identified by number as M2 and M3, which are similar enough in size and morphology to be combined for statistical analysis (TableΒ 1). Based on clustering in the PCA analysis, two phalanges cluster with the modern brown bears and there is no overlap with polar bears; one phalanx appears as an outlier (Fig.Β 3a). Measurements 2 and 6, i.e., the transversal diameter of the proximal end (DTprox), and the transversal diameter of the distal end (DTdist)[40], respectively, best separate the brown and polar bear reference individuals. A bivariate plot of these two measurements shows that all three unknown individuals overlap with the brown bear distribution; these are all smaller than the polar bear phalanges (Fig. S2). Regarding the metacarpals, three cluster with modern brown bear elements, and two are located at the intersection of the two clusters in morphospace and cannot be identified to species by PCA (Fig.Β 3b). However, a bivariate plot of the two measurements that best separate the reference brown and polar bear elements, i.e., measurements 6 and 8 (the transversal diameter of the distal end or DTdist, and the transversal diameter of the articular surface of the distal end or DTart.dist40), places all five metacarpals within the brown bear distribution (Fig. S3).

We were not able to assign the other 27 elements to species because of significant fragmentation, as well as intraspecific variability and sexual dimorphism in both brown bears11and polar bears64. In the Amaknak Bridge assemblage, none of the six specimens (three teeth, two femur fragments and a partial maxilla) could be assigned to species.

Aging and minimum number of animals

The bears range in age from young cub to adult (TableΒ 2). The most useful skeletal elements for aging were the scapula, radius, humerus, metapodials, calcaneus, tibia, mandible, femur, and phalanges. In the Margaret Bay assemblage, the femur with unfused distal and proximal ends has the porous, low-density quality of a neonatal cub, though measurements suggest it was likely avery young cub of 3-6 months old (Fig. S1). This identification should be refined using metric age models65, which do not yet exist for Alaska brown or polar bears. The unfused coracoid process of the scapula, unfused radius, and unfused distal humeri indicate cubs under the age of three. There are no clear subadult (age 3–4) specimens, but the phalanges and unfused tibia may fall into this category; specimens in the adult or mature category (over age 5) include the fused distal tibia, distal radius, distal humerus, distal femur, calcaneus, and fully fused metapodials. Aging analysis of loose teeth based on wear and tooth pulp cavity also suggested multiple age categories: we identified one immature incisor, two adult canines and one adult incisor. Significant wear on the polar bear molars in the mandible suggests that this animal was an adult.

Using the age categories, we have calculated a minimum number of individuals (MNI) for each site: the aged specimens from Margaret Bay represent five individuals: 1 neonatal bear or young cub, 2 cubs, and at least 2 adults (TableΒ 2). In the Amaknak Bridge assemblage, the unfused distal and proximal femur fragments indicate at least one adult or subadult bear (under age 5–6). The attrition present on the incisors and molar could also indicate an adult bear between 5 and 6 years55. The MNI represented by the Amaknak Bridge specimens is one.

Bone modification & pathologies

Anthropogenic modifications were observed on 10 bones from the Margaret Bay assemblage, including three metacarpals, three phalanges, the scapula and mandible, one tibia, and one radius (TableΒ 1). These modifications were interpreted as parallel clusters of v-shaped cut marks (Fig.Β 4). Pathologies were noted on one metacarpal and three teeth (TableΒ 1, Supplementary Table S1). One of the putative brown bear metacarpals exhibited significant growth of osteophytes near the proximal joint consistent with osteoarthritis62. Osteoarthritis has been observed in brown bears due to terrestrial running, climbing, and use of limbs to kill prey61, especially in older bears in zoological parks66. The two molars in the polar bear mandible and one loose incisor were heavily worn pre-mortem with significant attrition/abrasion53.

Among the Amaknak Bridge specimens, cut marks were found only on the proximal femur fragment. Attrition/abrasion was observed on both loose incisors and those within the maxilla. The molar was heavily worn to the gum line. We did not observe burning or carnivore gnawing in either collection, but noted both root etching and weathering on several elements in both collections. Notable root etching was found on the mandible, scapula, and metacarpal from Margaret Bay. While some amount of weathering did occur, the majority of the assemblage exhibited no or very little evidence of weathering (weathering stages 0–1), suggesting that for many contexts the remains were buried relatively rapidly. Three distal phalanges, radius, and calcaneus from Margaret Bay were moderately weathered (weathering stage 2–3) metacarpal 2 and canine tooth from Margaret Bay were heavily weathered (weathering stages 4) (Table S1).

Discussion

The results of the zooarchaeological analysis indicate that there is both polar bear and likely brown bear in the Margaret Bay assemblage (4700 rcyr BP), and one or both species in the Amaknak Bridge assemblage (2500 rcyr BP). However, given their morphological similarities, we were not able to identify 33 of the 39 specimens to species. In addition to this possible mix of bear species, we identified multiple animals in a variety of age classes, including one very young cub or possible neonate, two larger cubs, and at least three adults. The behavioral interpretations presented here are based on the sampling strategy described above; however, the story may change if we are able to gain access to the larger collection and the remaining large mammal specimens.

Overall, this assemblage of skeletal elements suggests that people were harvesting and processing bears close to Unalaska Bay, rather than trading for bear pelts or parts. If people were trading bear pelts, for example, we would expect to see only phalanges or other small elements that are often found as riders on pelts33,67. However, larger appendicular elements are present in both assemblages. It is unlikely that these larger skeletal elements (e.g. femur, tibia, humerus, and radius) were traded items and were instead deposited as larger, butchered parts68. In other regions, long bones were often targeted for marrow, grease, or tool-making69, which might make the bears attractive for trade. However, in the eastern Aleutian Islands, there is no local archaeological or ethnographic evidence of tool production using bear bone, or use of bear bone for grease production or marrow extraction in a place where marine mammals and fish provide plentiful sources of fat29. There is also a lack of ethnographic evidence of long-distance movement of other large animal carcasses after harvest.

The combination of cut marks on the phalanges, metacarpals, scapula, radius, and femur are consistent with skinning, disarticulation, and defleshing of the carcass70,71,72,73 (Fig.Β 4). Mature bear carcasses are very difficult to move and, in other regions, are normally butchered in the field so the meat and hide can be transported29. According to contemporary harvest data, bears are usually skinned and butchered immediately after death to avoid carcass decay and damage to the pelt, and for easier transport29,74,75. Therefore, the combination of ethnography, butchery marks, and the skeletal element profile suggest that the place of death and butchery were likely close by. Further analysis of the midden material could reveal additional skeletal elements or modifications not identified here.

The young cub femur offers additional evidence for a local harvest. In general, female polar and brown bears do not travel long distances while pregnant or with their young cubs76,77,78,79. Female brown bears give birth in dens in mid-winter, and after emergence in the spring females with dependent young tend to utilize small ranges for foraging58,77. Similarly, polar bear females give birth in dens in the winter, requiring deep snow pack for denning, and emerge in spring to forage37.Β Small cub bones are unlikely to have been traded because they hold limited technological value.

Finally, the molars in the polar bear mandible exhibit severe tooth wear, which may be associated with significant dietary changes. Such wear is not commonly seen in polar bears80Β because they eat a hypercarnivorous diet of soft seal flesh and blubber81. A recent analysis of dental wear in 21st century polar bears has attributed unusually excessive wear to the consumption of hard dietary items such as bones, which they are consuming as they spend more time on land scavenging80. While it is just a single specimen, it is possible that the bear deposited at Margaret Bay also consumed harder food items as it explored newly available habitat in Unalaska Bay.

This combination of zooarchaeological, biological, and ethnographic information is evidence for locally available brown and polar bears, and we argue that expanding Neoglacial sea ice facilitated the bears’ movement to Unalaska. Polar bears are pagophilic, meaning they require ice for hunting, traveling, and mating; therefore, sea ice extension into the southern Bering Sea during the Neoglacial could have extended the known range of polar bears6. Similarly, ice extension in Unimak Pass, which currently separates Unalaska and Unimak Islands (Fig.Β 1), could have facilitated extension of brown bear habitat west to Unalaska. Brown bears have very large seasonal movements on the Alaska Peninsula (as far as 740Β km76), and Unimak Island is separated from islands to the west by under 20Β km of sea. Brown bears have been observed traveling long distances over sea ice82 and are able to swim; for example, a brown bear was recently (summer 2024) observed to cross more than 5Β km of sea from the Alaska Peninsula to Unga Island (K. Reedy pers. comm.). This suggests that even if sea ice did not span the whole distance between Unimak and Unalaska, brown bears could have crossed through a combination of travel over ice, water, and island-hopping.

Based on the mortality profile, cut marks, and skeletal elements present, ancestral UnangaxΜ‚ harvested both polar and brown bears locally during the Neoglacial phase. The presence of bears means that hunters would have been faced with a novel predator on the landscape: bears would have offered the opportunity to harvest these large animals for meat, hides, and other products, but would have presented hunters with a dangerous and complicated hunting opportunity. However, UnangaxΜ‚ were well equipped to harvest large marine mammals, and vocabulary and oral history suggest people were aware of bears1. Elsewhere in Alaska, bears were considered a powerful and intelligent predator with anthropomorphic qualities83, and their hunt required specialized knowledge2. The remains of bears in the Unalaska Bay archaeological record suggests an unusual ecological relationship developed during the Neoglacial phase, whether people killed these bears in defense, for skins or meat, or for social reasons.

Conclusion

The evidence provided points to the bear remains from Unalaska Bay as being local, rather than traded items. While we do not have evidence from the full archaeological collection, we have used zooarchaeological methods on this smaller sample to demonstrate that people harvested and butchered bears in the past, and we conclude that they likely did so in the vicinity of Unalaska Bay. These conclusions support previous arguments that expanding sea ice facilitated bears’ movement to Unalaska Island, where people encountered and interacted with these novel species1,2,3,4. However, this study expands on previous knowledge with an analysis of the demography and treatment of the bears, and underscores the complexity of interpreting zooarchaeological material in changeable climatological and ecological conditions.

We used morphological and statistical analyses to demonstrate that the postcranial bear remains cannot be confidently assigned to species. While previous authors have treated the Amaknak Bridge and Margaret Bay specimens as polar bears5,6,85, we suggest that they are likely a combination of brown and polar bear. Furthermore, we were able to show that the assemblages include bears in different age classes and that these bears were harvested for their skins and for meat; while the bear bones and other parts were likely also used, we have no evidence for this. Together, the archaeological data suggest that both species of bear likely came to Unalaska on the expanding sea ice at the height of the Neoglacial phase, where they were then harvested by people.

The results of this zooarchaeological study support a complex ecological and climatological history for the eastern Aleutian Islands, and further support the argument that there is not a simple relationship among changing climate, animal behavior, and human behavior in the north86. We have highlighted the methodological standards necessary for interpreting this fragmentary assemblage and have provided morphological details about the taxa, which both provide a foundation for further analysis of this assemblage. For example, identifying the full bear assemblage to species would further complicate and enrich the story: bear behavior, habitat requirements, response to changing climate, and how they are hunted and used are dependent on species identification. Therefore, future research on this collection should employ stable isotope analysis to reconstruct bear diet, and ancient DNA to tell us how many individual bears are represented, whether they were male or female, and whether they came from a larger population somewhere else. The sample size could be increased by examining fragmentary material previously identified as β€œlarge land mammal”13using collagen protein fingerprinting (zooarchaeology by mass spectrometry or ZooMS). Finally, further ethnohistorical and new ethnographic research will contribute to archaeological interpretations of the human uses of, and interaction with, bears in this region. Together, these datasets will enhance and illuminate this complex story.