extra field in $* expansion when non-whitespace character in IFS
From:
Grisha Levit
Subject:
extra field in $* expansion when non-whitespace character in IFS
Date:
Sun, 9 Apr 2017 19:35:17 -0400
In most cases, removing a non-whitespace IFS character "delimits" a field
in the sense that it terminates it, so the presence of such a character at
the end of a field does not change its expansion:
$ IFS=X
$ set -- Y; printf '<%s>' $*
<Y>
$ set -- YX; IFS=X; printf '<%s>' $*
<Y>
However, when a positional parameter ends with a non-whitespace IFS character
and is followed by another positional parameter, the removal of the IFS
character seems to create an additional field:
$ set -- YX Y; printf '<%s>' $*
<Y><><Y>
Is this intentional? It sort of makes sense since $* is expanded as if it
were $1c$2 (where c is the first character of IFS), i.e. the expansion above
matches what is produced by
set -- YX Y; v=$*; printf '<%s>' $v
but that doesn't seem to respect the prescribed behavior of first producing
a field for each positional parameter, and then subjecting each field to
field splitting.
Array behavior matches positional parameter behavior here.
FWIW, this differs from the ksh behavior:
$ set -- YX Y; printf '<%s>' $*
<Y><Y>