Re: [PATCH] Add shopts for trailing newlines in command substitution and
From:
Koichi Murase
Subject:
Re: [PATCH] Add shopts for trailing newlines in command substitution and here strings
Date:
Fri, 29 Aug 2025 00:17:44 +0900
2025年8月28日(木) 17:29 Martin D Kealey <martin@kurahaupo.gen.nz>:
> On Wed, 27 Aug 2025 at 15:16, Koichi Murase <myoga.murase@gmail.com> wrote:
>> local saved=$(shopt -p cmdsubst_trailing_nls) # (assume we are in a
>> function)
>> shopt -s cmdsubst_trailing_nls
>> foo=$(some_command ...)
>> eval -- "$saved"
>
> Couldn't we just dictate that "local -" saves all set -o and shopt settings
> (or at least all new ones going forward)?
Or `local -I BASHOPTS' (as `local -' is for preserving `$-'). I
actually think it would be very useful in general.
However, in the present context, even with such a feature, we still
cannot simply write
foo=$(some_command ...)
but we need to write
local -
shopt -s cmdsubst_trailing_nls
foo=$(some_command ...)
in the general context where `cmdsubst_trailing_nls' may be changed by
others. Also, existing codebases of Bash frameworks need to be updated
to include
local -
shopt -u cmdsubst_trailing_nls
at the beginning of every function using any command substitutions.
It's simpler than « local saved=$(...) ... eval -- "$saved" », but the
fact that existing script codebases need global updates is unchanged.
--
Koichi