Hello Eric and all,
> On Wed, Jan 11, 2017 at 3:21 PM, Eric Blake <address@hidden> wrote:
>> there are strong arguments for including .lzip
>> distributions, either in addition or in place of .xz:
I would ask at least to keep XZ and not switch solely to lzip.
While I am in no position to evaluate lzip benchmark/robustness/format claims,
I do have some concerns about the lzip program:
First,
It is written in C++. Not a problem by itself, but seems a bit at odds as a
requirement for system-level package like coreutils.
Second,
I'm not sure how portable and well-tested the program is on the large number of
platforms that coreutils aim to cater to.
Being a C++ program, I'm not even sure if all these system could easily build
it or provide it as package.
Third,
I'm a bit wary of the closed development model: there is no public git
repository, only published tarballs, and not clear how active the development
or the community are.
Lastly,
I think the test suite is a bit lacking, especially compared to all the claims
about recovery and robustness of the lzip format.
---
I'm not saying 'xz' is perfect or that it answers all the above issues. But it
has a "community buy-in" which can't be denied compared to lzip.
If coreutils switches, I think it should switch to something that is provably
superior not only in benchmark/robustness.
Just my 2 cents,
- assaf