> > But in this case, what is it about the command line processing steps for
> > [ and [[, that the shell builtin test command, [, appears to have determined
> > this was an integer expression, but the shell keyword compound command, [[,
> > did not?
>
snippet..
> Builtin commands undergo word expansion before being executed. In this
> case, that means the words are expanded before being parsed as a
> conditional expression and evaluated. A command such as [[, which is part
> of the shell grammar, does not perform word expansion before the expression
> is parsed. That means that the operators in [[ are essentially tokens and
> must be present literally in order to be recognized by the shell parser.
snippet...
> [[ is evaluating the operands as arithmetic expressions when you use -eq
> -ne -lt etc... so "a" is taken as the name of a variable and an empty
> variable evaluates to 0.
'Literally present'... making sense... okay.
$a goes through expansion first and the whole arithmetic expression is then
handled, the "literal a" variable name defaults to 0 when unset/null.
If [ is a shell builtin, and [[ a shell keyword, asis {, what is (( to bash?
I know $(( is used in arithmetic substitution and (( arithmetic evaluation.
type test [ [[ { let \(\(
test is a shell builtin
[ is a shell builtin
[[ is a shell keyword
{ is a shell keyword
let is a shell builtin
bash: type: ((: not found
I've read forums, where folks will say [[ is enhanced [ or $(($a+1)) is the
same as $((a+1)), and on the surface the user may perceive that, but it
could cause problems down the line.
All responses were helpful.
Thank you.
Peggy Russell