Re: Fwd: No set builtin for exit on failure of an argument passed to a s
From:
Sabin p
Subject:
Re: Fwd: No set builtin for exit on failure of an argument passed to a simple command
Date:
Thu, 20 Nov 2025 15:32:06 -0500
I'm not proposing the behaviour of set -e should change, backwards
compatibility above all is critical to bash. I mostly just wanted to ask in
case the behaviour I seek was already implemented through some other
mechanism I wasn't aware of. If I was proposing anything it would be in the
form of a new set option to capture errors of arguments. Perhaps there's
some fundamental design constraint I'm not considering but it seems
counter-intuitive to me to explicitly want the capturing of errors in
command arguments to be unsupported.
Maybe it's too effortful to implement, or the general style of using -e
just doesn't align with the way developers write scripts so they see no
motivation for implementing such a feature. That's entirely fair too. In
any regard, thank you for your help.