Re: POSIX requires checking all *printf return values?!?
From:
Jim Meyering
Subject:
Re: POSIX requires checking all *printf return values?!?
Date:
Fri, 19 Oct 2007 17:51:20 +0200
PƔdraig Brady <address@hidden> wrote:
> Jim Meyering wrote:
>> I'm beginning to wonder if this is an error in the C library after all.
>> Surely POSIX doesn't intend to require that all programs test every
>> *printf return value. That would be silly. If so, what's the point
>> of the stream error indicator?
>
> You make a fair point.
> Perhaps the stream error indicator is just to indicate
> errors external to the program?
>
> I noticed a different work around in busybox
> which only works for single threaded progs
> (which should be fine for coreutils).
>http://www.busybox.net/downloads/patches/svn-14627.patch
Thanks.
It might be better in the long run (if ever vendor *printf start working
how one would expect), to provide replacement printf and fprintf functions
that *do* set the stream indicator for those case. But for now, I've pushed
the new xprintf module, with a few tiny additional changes, and will
probably change printf.c to use it.