On Mon, Apr 21, 2008 at 9:27 AM, Almer S. Tigelaar <address@hidden> wrote:
> Hello,
>
> I have been using the 'wc' program (version 5.97) to manually verify
> some counts outputted by a component part of an application I am
> developing.
>
> I noticed that:
> echo "12345" | wc -m
> Gives me '6' as output. But I don't entirely understand why.
>
> On multi-line input 'wc' seems to add '1' to the character count in each
> sentence. One would say then that this '1' is caused by counting
> 'invisible' newline characters, but there is no newline in the example
> above.
>
> This off-by-one is probably intended behaviour (even though I am curious
> to find out why). I would expect something about this to be listed in
> the man page of 'wc', but could not find it there.
Its counting the trailing newline.
$ echo "12345" | wc -m
6
$ printf "12345\n" | wc -m
6
$ printf "12345" | wc -m
5
$ echo -n "12345" | wc -m
5
Brock