Caerus
"Everyone is an NPC, until proven otherwise."
My Grading Scale from 1-10
10/10 - Can only be 1
9/10 - Some of the best out there, I will die on this hill that these are my favorites and push anyone willing to talk to me to watch them regardless of preferences
8/10 - I really really enjoy these but they usually have 1-2 major problems usually being bad MC or bad / unfinished endings, Highly recommended
6 - 7/10: These are above average, I usually latch on to 1-2 aspect of the show I enjoy but the rest is kinda bad/meh, I will be pretty picky on recommending these to anyone
4-5/10: these are just average... idk why I even finished them, recommendations are far and few between
bellow 4.5/10: I will recommend people to NOT watch these, as they wasted my time, I finished very few of these, and I will write a paper on why they are so bad
**Usually when I rate with a 0.25/0.5 I tend to round down not up
*One piece score is an ongoing average I have on an external spreadsheet that is averaging every arc. I am watching the One-Pace fan edit as the pacing of OP is frankly unwatchable in its original form. Link bellow if you would like to partake.
Events



All Comments (27) Comments
why not? It was the only good etna gif
It comes from the desire to annoy/chat with someone whose way of seeing things they don't understand
Again Turn A wasn't "bad" for gundam. It brought back viewership when people were just about to have Gundam fatigue. Just because it was weird and didn't get to the milestones of SEED doesn't mean it was a net-negative for Sunrise.
Also with GQUUUUUUX, your review doesn't exactly have any evidence to support your basis that your opinion is emotionally based. So i just went with logic as that's where GQUUUUX falls apart. I can't argue with you on your emotional response but your review is a bit confusing in that manner. I'm also interested in understanding how you think UC fails to tell their stories properly.
Turn A's lack of popularity doesn't make it hated, it was never meant to be for mass appeal. There are various testimonies from VA's that say Tomino aimed to address the audience 50 years later with Turn A.
It is also not a failure. Why would a failure have compilation movies made of it? Why would a failure have 50 episodes go on. Why would a failure remain in conversation now as a magnum opus of Tomino's oeuvre? Why was its TV ratings above that of X and stable throughout its runtime? Why does Tomino label it as his mental recovery? It failed on nothing it tried to do. As I said, using popularity as a metric was never exactly Turn A's intention
Also if you call Turn A a bad Gundam show I sincerely doubt your understanding of the franchise. It continues every theme from the original but in a tighter package that doesn't leave room for interpretation. The meaning of newtype has been lost yes, but Dianna and Kihel still remain as one of the best depictions of the intent Tomino had with newtypes. Tomino goes further into the environmentalism he was discovering around CCA, he develops his factions further than Gundam ever has even to this day and he writes a show where a protagonist who straddles several identities finds his purpose by the end, which not many protagonists in Gundam ever have the fulfillment of doing.
The show also misappropriates commentary from the past to say something about now. Lalah is not some space witch whose power transcends time, newtypes simply don't do that. They're the final form of human empathy. Lalah's empathy is selfish in a way, even Amuro acknowledges this when he says "you can't have both of us!" in CCA. The axis shock was always meant to be Amuro exhaling humanity's final breath in the tension of Earth being destroyed, which is why its so powerful compared to every other Newtype feat. Lalah doing that by HERSELF simply makes 0 sense.
The show also simplifies Lalah into a trophy of Char's, which is frankly abhorrent. In a novel by Tomino, she alone flees from the brothel. Yet in the anime, she's constantly reduced to a damsel waiting for Char and wholly reliant on him, to the point of making a new dimension. You can say Char was a groomer yes, but Lalah was simply never this reliant on Char.
ALSO Char's Counterattack has nothing to do with GQUUUUUX unless you have to compare it thematically, which is where you notice GQUUUUX fall apart. CCA is in UC 0093, far past the Gryps Conflict with the Titans and Flanagan institutes and whatevers.
And you simply lie about Turn A being hated on release. It wasn't. It was certainly not that popular, but it had its fanbase for what was very experimental and far removed from the shows before it. Turn A was considered Tomino's best work and it still is polling that high. Comparing the criticism GQUUUUUX got to Turn A with no evidence makes your review look a whole lot less credible
have you seen devilman crybaby?
there were points in the animation that were some of the worst anime I've seen in my life, and part of this show was reminiscent of that
"the director did great work, however the animation was Devilman crybaby bad at some points"
What the fuck did this even mean?
There is a reason why everybody is on fire in your comment section lol...
Also I happen to watch a lot of good/alright stuff (mostly recommended by others) that's why my average is 8.17, doesn't mean I won't give other animes a try that might end up being 6 or below, it is really that simple and literally the whole world agrees with me as well. I'll say it again in case you didn't get it, this isn't about you disliking animes because you just didn't like 'em, this is mostly about how you don't rate things properly and how your ratings contradict whatever logic and ruleset you're following. I am in shock that Edgerunners is 9/10 but AOT and other decent/good animes are 6 or below LMAO
with that being said, get rid of your ego, nobody is here to judge you or burn you, I just wanted to point out something that makes no sense and is confusing to every living creature, and you immediately started attacking me for no reason
i just wanna say the way you rate stuff is illogical, overcritical and possibly even skewed
for an example, how come you rate csm over aot? in what world is csm better than aot considering you're pretending to be one of those elite people who seek "the best"
you can only rate csm so high if you're biased or if you are open minded, and your statement that only 1 can be 10/10 is also flawed (alongside your entire rating system) and contradicts the very definition of perfection