help-bash
[Top][All Lists]
Advanced

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: I am concerned about the future of FOSS projects


From: microsuxx
Subject: Re: I am concerned about the future of FOSS projects
Date: Sun, 6 Jul 2025 15:16:07 +0200

keep promises .. free is free ..

On Sun, Jul 6, 2025, 12:34 AM Heime <heimeborgia@protonmail.com> wrote:

> Jesus Christ on a pogo stick, have you read this digital apocalypse
> fantasy? Some keyboard warrior out there is losing his mind, going
> full-on Mad Max.
>
> What, are you smoking digital crack?
>
> And the United Nations?  Yeah, that's the ticket.  Let's get a bunch of
> bureaucratic suits who can't even agree on what day it after being found
> sleeping through sessions.  Because nothing says "efficient" like theso
> committees who spend half their time arguing over lunch menus and the
> other half passing meaningless resolutions.
>
> And the idea that maintainers should just retire and hand over the
> shit to corporate drones for exploitation? That's comedy gold.
> The fate of civilization does not rest on a few open-source projects
> on GitHub, and the United Nations is not the hope for humanity's digital
> future.  What's next?  The World Health Organization prescribing patches
> for your operating system?
>
> Sometimes a little code goes sideways and you get a Heartbleed or a
> Log4Shell.
> But the hysteria?  That's the real virus.  It's like watching a toddler
> panic
> because they dropped their ice cream.
>
> 1. The Nonsense of “Vast Importance” Claims
>
> Yes, FOSS Is Important.  However, the idea that civilization is
> "one maintainer's bad day away from collapse" is a dramatic
> exaggeration. Most critical systems have layers of redundancy,
> backups.
>
> Real-world outages (like left-pad, Heartbleed, Log4Shell) cause
> headaches, cost money, and sometimes create security risks. But
> they do not send us back to the Stone Age.
>
> 2. The Nonsense of “UN Must Save Us”
>
> Why Would the United Nations Run Your Code?  The UN is a diplomatic
> body, not a global IT department. It's not equipped to audit, maintain,
> or fund software projects.  Even if the UN "took control", it would
> introduce bureaucracy, not agility or resilience.
>
> What Actually Works?
>
>     What works is the diversity of maintainers: The best defense is more
>     eyes, more contributors, and more transparency - not a single "world
>     maintainer".
>
> 3. The Nonsense of “Apocalyptic Collapse”
>
> Software Bugs are not the End of Civilization
>
>     Yes, bugs can cause outages, breaches, and data loss. But the
>     notion that a bug in Core-JS or ImageMagick triggers collapse
>     is pure fiction.
>
> The “One Maintainer to Rule Them All” Fallacy
>
>     Many projects are indeed underfunded and under-maintained. But the
>     solution is community support, not panic or UN intervention.
>
>     The "all maintainers should retire" idea is absurd - without
> passionate,
>     skilled maintainers, software would wither.
>
> Overblown Fears
>
>     "Collapse of civilization" is not on the table. At worst, we face
>     outages, security incidents, and disruption—serious, but not
>     existential.
>
>     The idea that "companies should stop using FOSS" is both
>     impractical and counterproductive.  FOSS is the solution,
>     not the problem.
>
> What Won't Help?
>
>     UN "taking over".
>
>     Mass retirements of maintainers.
>
>     Lawsuits against companies for using open source (which is, by
>     definition, licensed for use).
>
>
>
>
> On Sunday, July 6th, 2025 at 8:40 AM, William Richards #SaveOurInternet <
> corpseleague@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> > I know this is quite out of the ordinary for your average email here,
> but I
> > don’t think that huge corporations, let alone the entire internet, should
> > be relying on FOSS projects to run. There have been multiple incidents
> > regarding the FOSS foundation issue already, like Log4Shell, XZ Utils’s
> > backdoor and OpenSSL’s Heartbleed bug.
> >
> >
> > At this point, there have been so many incidents that we genuinely just
> > cannot afford any more.
> >
> >
> > I am William Richards (https://x.com/CorpseLeague) and I am hosting a
> > movement to fix the FOSS project foundation problem for good so the
> > internet can be a safe place for everyone.
> >
> >
> > I have written an article of the details of the issue too, listing every
> > known FOSS project in the community;
> >
> https://medium.com/@corpseleague/dear-united-nations-the-internets-fragile-foss-foundations-pose-a-risk-to-humanity-2e98fdd94bd9
> >
> >
> > I have additionally contacted a UN member about this so they can get this
> > information to the United Nations;
> > https://x.com/mcraddock/status/1941039486122787201
> >
> >
> > I am additionally going to reach out to Jen Gentleman about this as she
> has
> > a lot of power in Microsoft to fix this issue.
> >
> >
> > I may have also accidentally leaked the article's information to a
> sleeper
> > agent (although I’m not sure), so just to be safe, if you have someone
> > fairly new (at least a month since they've began contributing to your
> > project) contributing to your project asking to be a maintainer, be very
> > cautious when you trust them. This is just so another XZ Utils incident
> > doesn't happen again.
> >
> >
> > Mark will get the article with the information on the FOSS problem to the
> > UN so we won’t have to worry about bugs in FOSS projects breaking the
> > entire internet anymore.
> >
> >
> > I suggest getting in touch with every FOSS maintainer listed in the
> article
> > so we can form a community against the destruction of humanity.
>
>


reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]