help-bash
[Top][All Lists]
Advanced

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: I am concerned about the future of FOSS projects


From: Kenneth Loafman
Subject: Re: I am concerned about the future of FOSS projects
Date: Sun, 6 Jul 2025 10:51:17 -0500

The rest of us worry about proprietary products that no one can review,
like Microsoft, Oracle, any of the Election Machine manufacturers, etc.

Remember, the net and its infrastructure are all built on FOSS products.
That was true more than a decade before the proprietary nonsense began.  I
don't worry about FOSS products, I worry about secretive proprietary ones.
That's more a security risk than FOSS ever was.

...Ken


On Sun, Jul 6, 2025 at 8:17 AM microsuxx <fxmbsw7@gmail.com> wrote:

> remember freenode irc sold
> so the unloyal shit
>
> On Sun, Jul 6, 2025, 3:16 PM microsuxx <fxmbsw7@gmail.com> wrote:
>
>> keep promises .. free is free ..
>>
>> On Sun, Jul 6, 2025, 12:34 AM Heime <heimeborgia@protonmail.com> wrote:
>>
>>> Jesus Christ on a pogo stick, have you read this digital apocalypse
>>> fantasy? Some keyboard warrior out there is losing his mind, going
>>> full-on Mad Max.
>>>
>>> What, are you smoking digital crack?
>>>
>>> And the United Nations?  Yeah, that's the ticket.  Let's get a bunch of
>>> bureaucratic suits who can't even agree on what day it after being found
>>> sleeping through sessions.  Because nothing says "efficient" like theso
>>> committees who spend half their time arguing over lunch menus and the
>>> other half passing meaningless resolutions.
>>>
>>> And the idea that maintainers should just retire and hand over the
>>> shit to corporate drones for exploitation? That's comedy gold.
>>> The fate of civilization does not rest on a few open-source projects
>>> on GitHub, and the United Nations is not the hope for humanity's digital
>>> future.  What's next?  The World Health Organization prescribing patches
>>> for your operating system?
>>>
>>> Sometimes a little code goes sideways and you get a Heartbleed or a
>>> Log4Shell.
>>> But the hysteria?  That's the real virus.  It's like watching a toddler
>>> panic
>>> because they dropped their ice cream.
>>>
>>> 1. The Nonsense of “Vast Importance” Claims
>>>
>>> Yes, FOSS Is Important.  However, the idea that civilization is
>>> "one maintainer's bad day away from collapse" is a dramatic
>>> exaggeration. Most critical systems have layers of redundancy,
>>> backups.
>>>
>>> Real-world outages (like left-pad, Heartbleed, Log4Shell) cause
>>> headaches, cost money, and sometimes create security risks. But
>>> they do not send us back to the Stone Age.
>>>
>>> 2. The Nonsense of “UN Must Save Us”
>>>
>>> Why Would the United Nations Run Your Code?  The UN is a diplomatic
>>> body, not a global IT department. It's not equipped to audit, maintain,
>>> or fund software projects.  Even if the UN "took control", it would
>>> introduce bureaucracy, not agility or resilience.
>>>
>>> What Actually Works?
>>>
>>>     What works is the diversity of maintainers: The best defense is more
>>>     eyes, more contributors, and more transparency - not a single "world
>>>     maintainer".
>>>
>>> 3. The Nonsense of “Apocalyptic Collapse”
>>>
>>> Software Bugs are not the End of Civilization
>>>
>>>     Yes, bugs can cause outages, breaches, and data loss. But the
>>>     notion that a bug in Core-JS or ImageMagick triggers collapse
>>>     is pure fiction.
>>>
>>> The “One Maintainer to Rule Them All” Fallacy
>>>
>>>     Many projects are indeed underfunded and under-maintained. But the
>>>     solution is community support, not panic or UN intervention.
>>>
>>>     The "all maintainers should retire" idea is absurd - without
>>> passionate,
>>>     skilled maintainers, software would wither.
>>>
>>> Overblown Fears
>>>
>>>     "Collapse of civilization" is not on the table. At worst, we face
>>>     outages, security incidents, and disruption—serious, but not
>>>     existential.
>>>
>>>     The idea that "companies should stop using FOSS" is both
>>>     impractical and counterproductive.  FOSS is the solution,
>>>     not the problem.
>>>
>>> What Won't Help?
>>>
>>>     UN "taking over".
>>>
>>>     Mass retirements of maintainers.
>>>
>>>     Lawsuits against companies for using open source (which is, by
>>>     definition, licensed for use).
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> On Sunday, July 6th, 2025 at 8:40 AM, William Richards #SaveOurInternet <
>>> corpseleague@gmail.com> wrote:
>>>
>>> > I know this is quite out of the ordinary for your average email here,
>>> but I
>>> > don’t think that huge corporations, let alone the entire internet,
>>> should
>>> > be relying on FOSS projects to run. There have been multiple incidents
>>> > regarding the FOSS foundation issue already, like Log4Shell, XZ Utils’s
>>> > backdoor and OpenSSL’s Heartbleed bug.
>>> >
>>> >
>>> > At this point, there have been so many incidents that we genuinely just
>>> > cannot afford any more.
>>> >
>>> >
>>> > I am William Richards (https://x.com/CorpseLeague) and I am hosting a
>>> > movement to fix the FOSS project foundation problem for good so the
>>> > internet can be a safe place for everyone.
>>> >
>>> >
>>> > I have written an article of the details of the issue too, listing
>>> every
>>> > known FOSS project in the community;
>>> >
>>> https://medium.com/@corpseleague/dear-united-nations-the-internets-fragile-foss-foundations-pose-a-risk-to-humanity-2e98fdd94bd9
>>> >
>>> >
>>> > I have additionally contacted a UN member about this so they can get
>>> this
>>> > information to the United Nations;
>>> > https://x.com/mcraddock/status/1941039486122787201
>>> >
>>> >
>>> > I am additionally going to reach out to Jen Gentleman about this as
>>> she has
>>> > a lot of power in Microsoft to fix this issue.
>>> >
>>> >
>>> > I may have also accidentally leaked the article's information to a
>>> sleeper
>>> > agent (although I’m not sure), so just to be safe, if you have someone
>>> > fairly new (at least a month since they've began contributing to your
>>> > project) contributing to your project asking to be a maintainer, be
>>> very
>>> > cautious when you trust them. This is just so another XZ Utils incident
>>> > doesn't happen again.
>>> >
>>> >
>>> > Mark will get the article with the information on the FOSS problem to
>>> the
>>> > UN so we won’t have to worry about bugs in FOSS projects breaking the
>>> > entire internet anymore.
>>> >
>>> >
>>> > I suggest getting in touch with every FOSS maintainer listed in the
>>> article
>>> > so we can form a community against the destruction of humanity.
>>>
>>>


reply via email to

[Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread]